A Harvey Hotel
How the West Was Won
The Harvey Girls came into being in the early years of railroads. Before railroads included dining cars on their trains, a railroad passenger's only option for meals while travelling was to eat at a roadhouse near a water stop, en route. The food was terrible! Rancid meat, cold beans, and week-old coffee. The trip out west, from New York to Sante Fe by rail, took about five days, and these conditions discouraged many travellers, until the advent of Fred Harvey and the Harvey Girls.
Fred Harvey, who was a railroad freight agent, saw an opportunity there.
The Atchison, Topeka and Sante Fe Railroad Company contracted with Harvey for several eating houses along the route west. Harvey staffed his places with the "Harvey Girls"; waitresses with very high standards.
The subsequent growth and development of the Fred Harvey Company was closely related to that of the Sante Fe Railway. Harvey opened his first depot restaurant in Topeka, Kansas, in January of 1876. Railway officials and customers alike were impressed with Fred Harvey's strict standards for high-quality food and first class Harvey Girl service. As a result, the Sante Fe Railway enetered into subsequent contracts where Harvey was given a "blank check" to set up eating houses along the entire route west. At more prominent locations, these restaurants evolved into hotels, many of which survive today, though not many are open for business. The Harvey Girls were almost as famous as the Harvey restaurants and hotels along the railroad route west.
Of the eighty-four Fred Harvey facilities, some of the more notable include:
- The Alvarado — Albuquerque, New Mexico; closed in 1969. Demolished. Exhibit at the Albuquerque Museum of Art and History (March 8- June 7, 2009.)
- The Bisonte — Hutchinson, Kansas; closed in 1946
- The Casa del Desierto — Barstow, California; closed in 1959. Refurbished 1999; operating as two museums and city offices.
- Castañeda — Las Vegas, New Mexico; closed in 1948, used in the film Red Dawn
- El Garces — Needles, California; closed in 1958. Undergoing restoration (2008).
- El Navajo — Gallup, New Mexico; closed in 1957.
- El Ortiz — Lamy, New Mxico; closed in 1938.
- El Otero — La Junta, California; closed in 1948.
- El Tovar — Grand Canyon, Arizona; still in operation.
- El Vaquero — Dodge City, Kansas; closed in 1948.
- The Havasu House — Seligman, Arizona; closed in 1955. Demolished 2008.
- The Escalante — Ash Fork, Arizona; closed in 1948, demolished in the 1970s
- The Fray Marcos — Williams, Arizona; restored and reopened as a historic hotel and train depot for the Grand Canyon Railway
- La Fonda — Sante Fe, New Mexico; still in operation
- Las Chavez — Vaughn, New Mexico; closed in 1936
- La Posada — Winslow, Arizona; closed in 1957; restored and reopened as a historic hotel
- The Sequoyah — Syracuse, Kansas; closed in 1936
Harvey Girl Poster--The Orange Empire Railroad Museum
Fred Harvey's biggest challenge was not delivering fresh food to his far-flung outposts but finding reliable help. So he placed advertisements in the East and the Midwest for single "young women, 18 to 30 years of age, of good character, attractive and intelligent."
These women became the famed Harvey Girl waitresses, trained in rules of etiquette and given black-and-white uniforms befitting a nun. Humorist Will Rogers once said Harvey and his Harvey Girls "kept the West in food and wives." Indeed, one estimate put the number of Harvey Girls who wound up as brides of western cowboys and railroad men at 20,000.
Mrs. Harvey met each girl as she was hired. Mrs. Harvey had strict standards of etiquetteand codes of behavior, and the prospective aHarvey Girl had to measure up. The jobs were considered plum positions in those days. Paid $17.50 a month, this was a dream job for many young girls who were unable to find work in Eastern cities, with the burgeoning populations of big cities like New York, Boston and Philadelphia.
Many Harvey Girls, who were always respectable, left their employment as a Harvey Girl to became the wife to a customer. One railroad baron said "The Harvey House was not only a good place to eat; it was the Cupid of the Rails". It is estimated that more than 100,000 girls worked for Harvey House restaurants and hotels and of those, 20,000 married their regular customers
How Did They Do It?
How these girls did it, I'll never know. The rules were strict: No fraternizing with the guests. Fred Harvey, who would overturn tables in a fit of temper if he was displeased with the way it was set, was a real stickler for the rules. Any least infraction would result in instant dismissal, without the rest of the person's pay. Fred Harvey advanced the girls a train ticket and half their first month's pay on hiring them, but expected them to keep their end of the bargain, and work the full year's contract, abiding by every strict rule he imposed.
It drove him CRAZY!! His staff kept getting married out from underneath him, over and over. At one point, a rule was imposed that a Harvey girl could not sit down, anywhere, while on duty. Harvey girls were on duty twelve to fourteen hours per day.
How DID they do it? How did they find a way to establish enough of a relationship to get married, without being able to talk to their suitors, or even sit down in their company; while wearing black hosiery, black dresses with white aprons, full length, to the floor; high collars, hair back, no makeup...I love it. These Harvey Girls kept working miracles!
For MORE, click HERE:
- Women in History-Jennie Churchill
Jennie Churchill--an icon of her era, and mother of Winston Churchill; the key to his success.
- Coco Chanel, Queen of Haute Couture
Coco Chanel, the Queen of Haute Couture--the life and times of Coco Chanel. A fascinating story of a woman going from rags to riches on the strength of her talents and personality.
- Women in History-Gertrude Bell
Step back in time with the most dynamic traveller of her era-Gertrude Bell.
Stephanie Ulrich on October 14, 2017:
My Mother, Helen Espy, was a Harvey Girl in Kansas City. Met my father there. 1939.
deepope on May 18, 2015:
grandmother was Harvey girl. How can I find more info on her time as Harvey girl?
Kelly Umphenour from St. Louis, MO on July 04, 2012:
Hey Paradise! This is fabulous! The day of the Harvey Girls was fascinating wasn't it? I hope you don't mind I linked this hub to my newest so I wouldn't have to go into an explanation as you did it so beautifully for me!
Paradise7 (author) from Upstate New York on August 27, 2011:
Thankyou, vocal coach, for the comment. I found this subject fascinating. These girls were actually quite brave, and very hard-working.
Audrey Hunt from Pahrump NV on August 26, 2011:
I remember Seeing the Harvey Girls in a Judy Garland Movie a few yrs ago. So this hub is so very interesting to me. I enjoyed the story and the photos are great.
You've done an excellent job researching this information. I'm rating up! Thank you.
Paradise7 (author) from Upstate New York on April 28, 2011:
Thanks, fastfreta, I thought it was cool, too, that Ted's mom was a Harvey Girl. I wish I could have interviewed her for the article.
Alfreta Sailor from Southern California on April 27, 2011:
This is a great story Paradise7. How cool Ted Kimbler's mother was a Harvey Girl. You know I vaguely remember hearing about these women in the movies. Anyway, very well written. Voted up/useful/awesome.
Ted Kimbler on March 02, 2011:
My mom was a Harvey Girl and that's where she met my dad.
Kylie Jenkins on November 23, 2010:
that was good
Paradise7 (author) from Upstate New York on August 08, 2010:
Thank you, Dolores. I enjoyed this story so much, I just had to share it.
Dolores Monet from East Coast, United States on August 07, 2010:
What a great tribute to the Harvey Girls. I love the old ads and the story was great.
Paradise7 (author) from Upstate New York on July 15, 2010:
Oh, this is great!!!! You actually knew a Harvey Girl! How much I would've liked to interview your grandmother and her friend for this hub. Thanks for the comment.
SallyMae on July 15, 2010:
What a great place for information. My grandmother and her friend were Harvey Girls from Chicago around 1914 and went to work in Wendover, Wyoming. She married one of Fred Harvey's cooks!
Paradise7 (author) from Upstate New York on May 02, 2010:
Thank you, A Evans! It sounds like a wonderful trip!
Julianna from SomeWhere Out There on May 02, 2010:
What an amazing story and you wrote it so well, I enjoy learning history that is enlightening and not boring to read, you did a great job! I must travel up to the Grand Canyon this summmer and check-out the Hotel thanks so much for the wonderful hub! :)
Paradise7 (author) from Upstate New York on September 19, 2009:
Thank you, Catherine & Matthew. I think there WAS a real shortage of women. More men, by a lot, than women. I LIKE those odds!
Matthew 43 on September 18, 2009:
Catherine R from Melbourne, Australia on September 12, 2009:
This was great - absolutely news to me. Seems like it must have been the uniform! But there must also have been a bit of a shortage of respectable women in the far flung outposts so I am guessing these girls were in great demand. Fascinating stuff.
Sylvia Van Velzer from Hawaii on September 12, 2009:
What an exciting job, to be a Harvey Girl! Food and men, you can't go wrong. Love this historical hysterical hub!
Paradise7 (author) from Upstate New York on September 12, 2009:
Thank you Dohn. That explains it--it was the uniform. The guy just had to find out what was underneath it, and since these were all very respectable and well-protected women, he had to marry her!
dohn121 from Hudson Valley, New York on September 12, 2009:
To me, I don't see how it isn't possible! Many men (ask the Japanese who adore their Geishas) love obscurity...Leaving much to the imagination can be very much a "turn on." When a Geisha wants to grab a hold of their male customer, she will show him her wrist! Her neck can also be a very sexy revealing body part! I myself for some reason or another, have a penchant for cashiers and waitresses. I just don't know why. I guess when I do get married, my wife and I aren't allowed to eat out or buy anything :( Oh well!
Thank you, Paradise7! What an awesome hub!
Paradise7 (author) from Upstate New York on September 12, 2009:
You're very welcome, AW
awsydney from Sydney, Australia on September 12, 2009:
Wow, never knew there was such rich history about them! Thanks for sharing.