Skip to main content

Amelia Island: Dining Guide

Florida Vacations

If you love Florida vacations as much as I do, be sure to visit beautiful Amelia Island. If you're planning a trip to Amelia Island, Florida, you'll be bombarded with dining choices, ranging from fast food to four-star dining and everything in between. As a regular visitor to the island, here are a few suggestions:

Sliders: It's kind of an unwritten law that a visit to the island must include a meal at Sliders. It's right on the beach, on Fletcher. You can't miss it. This old favorite has been around for years. Some of their items are a little overpriced, but it's definitely worth a visit. I can honestly say I got the best steak I've ever had in any restaurant at Sliders. It was a little over $20, but it was worth every penny. You also need to try their oysters.

Cedar River: Located on Saddler, Cedar River has wonderful fried seafood at reasonable prices. There's nothing fancy about this place, but it's clean and offers good service. Their fried shrimp, fried oysters, and hush puppies are golden brown and never greasy. Sometimes they have an all-you-can-eat grouper special for a ridiculously low price. Just check the sign by the road - they'll announce the special there.

Sand Dollar: This restaurant is located on Heckscher Drive. It has a Jacksonville address, but it's a short drive from Amelia Island, and what a beautiful drive it is! The restaurant is right on the St. John's River, and there's an outside eating area for waterfront dining. One night a week they have an awesome seafood buffet, which usually also includes beef rib roast. Another night of the week they have an all-you-can-eat crableg special. Make sure you go with a big appetite.

Florida House Inn: Florida's oldest surviving hotel, the Florida House Inn was built in 1857. It's a bed-and-breakfast now, but its dining room is open to the public for breakfast and lunch. Lunch is served boardinghouse style, with heaping platters of Southern foods. If the large dining room is crowded, you might end up sitting with strangers - who usually become friends by the end of the meal. The food is good and reasonably priced, and the hotel itself is worth seeing. The Innis located on 3rd Street, near downtown Fernandina Beach.

O'Kanes's Irish Pub: Located downtown on Centre Street, O'Kane's has great atmosphere and good food. My favorites include the shepherd's pie, the baked brie, and the black angus burger. The service is friendly and laid back, and it has comfy traditional pub-style chairs at most of the tables. There's also a small bar up front.

The Surf: Across the street from the beach, on Fletcher, The Surf is another old favorite. They have a large outdoor seating area, and on most nights they feature live music. The night crowd consists mostly of young people, especially on the weekends, but a few old fogies (like me) are also always in attendance. They have wonderful wings and appetizers, and sometimes they feature all-you-can-eat specials, including lobster. This is a great place to go to enjoy appetizers and drinks and to party!

The Marina: A long-standing establishment, The Marina is located in downtown Fernandina Beach, at the end of Centre Street. It's a favorite with locals and has been for decades. There's nothing fancy about the place, but it does have a certain charm. My favorite entree here is the crab-stuffed shrimp. Yum!

Barbara Jean's: Located on A1A, just after you cross Shave Bridge to get on the island, Barbara Jean's features a large menu consisting of seafood dishes and old Southern favorites. Many claim that their crab cakes are as good as the ones served in Baltimore. They have great homemade sides, like a scrumptious squash casserole, and their homemade bread is amazing. Order the mixed bread basket!

Beautiful Amelia Island, Florida.

Beautiful Amelia Island, Florida.

Enjoy lots of fresh seafood on the island!

Enjoy lots of fresh seafood on the island!


Daniel Christian from Los Angeles, CA on October 30, 2011:

When I lived in Jacksonville in 2008 I became all to familiar with Amelia Island. Great place with great restaurants and hotels.

Holle Abee (author) from Georgia on May 02, 2011:

Hi, Mo! Yes, we love dining at both of those Amelia Island restaurants. One of the best things about Florida vacations is the fresh seafood!

mocrow from Georgia on March 02, 2011:

Love your Amelia Island Dining Guide! We ate at Cedar River and Barbara Jean's last weekend, and both were great!

Holle Abee (author) from Georgia on June 09, 2010:

Judie, we love Fernandina! I've been going there for vacations my entire life! I've written numerous articles about it! Thanks for reading!

Judie Mackie from Amelia Island, FL on June 08, 2010:

Scroll to Continue

I live on Amelia Island and am the editor of where you can find the latest news and informaton. Restaurants come and go, but many seem to be staples in the community. It is great to hear how many love coming to Fernandina Beach! The next time you visit listen close to the sea, you will hear it whisper, "Welcome Home!"

Holle Abee (author) from Georgia on March 26, 2010:

Pretty good, usually - except for when the water's calm.

Gregory on March 25, 2010:

Hows the surfing out there?

Holle Abee (author) from Georgia on March 13, 2010:

Herbi, did the condos have a pier?? I love Amelia Island and have written several hubs about it!

theherbivorehippi from Holly, MI on March 11, 2010:

How have I never noticed this hub from you?? When my grandmother was alive, my grandparents were spend most of their winters every years at a condo on the ocean on Amelia island. These were by far my favorite memories growing up...walking the beach every morning with my grandpa and my grandma I going shopping at all of the awesome shops. I love this place!! What an awesome hub!!!

tsjjdfscdkkid on January 14, 2010:

THE 7TH LETTER kicked off their latest project with New Era as blue ugg classic boots they showcased both their world famous art as well as a new set of collaboration cardy ugg boots fitted caps last night. With the 59FIFTY serving as the template, cardy ugg boots uk the designs of Eklips, Revok, Sever, Push, and Ewok are seen alongside some impressive canvasses. The whole event took place at Santa Monica’s James Gray Gallery Bergamot Station.

Source: Black ugg classic boots The Gluttony

cc on November 16, 2009:

Welcome to buy top quality nike sb dunk, dunks shoes with worldwide free shipping.We guarantee 100 % secure payment and low price.

Holle Abee (author) from Georgia on November 15, 2009:

Wrong! Where ya been, Ed? You have it mixed up with some other restaurant. As of today - 11/15/09, the Sand Dollar is still open, and they have no plans of closing. You can call them at 904-251-2449 to verify, if you like.

Thanks for reading, anyway!

Ed on November 15, 2009:

Info here out of date Sand dollar closed years ago!!!!

mtwzh123 on September 02, 2009:

Thanks meanjoegreen for presenting that warning so clearly. What you say makes sense.

Related Articles