Skip to main content

Why Anti-Abortion Laws Don't Work

This author enjoys writing about life, love, and books. She enjoys watching anime and munching on burgers.

Understanding Abortion Laws

Abortion is widely considered to be a moral, societal, and political issue. From the pro-life and pro-choice campaigns, to women's rights issues and fetal rights issues, there's no doubt that there's a thick air of complexity surrounding the two. What's more, multiple forms of legislation have been passed regarding these issues, and court cases on the matter have resulted in verdicts that are, at the very least, unclear. This has led states to pass their own laws regarding abortion, many of which have led to the passing of anti-abortion legislation.

A Brief History of American Anti-Abortion Laws

Abortion legislation has had a long, complicated history in America. Generally speaking, abortion laws have been used to regulate, restrict, permit, or even outright prohibit abortion entirely. These laws have been dictated by both liberals and conservatives alike, as well as other decisive political decisions that have affected many lives, regardless of gender or age.

Abortion had started to take the center stage of politics when, in 1973, the U.S Supreme Court ruled in Roe vs. Wade ruled that abortion should be legalized nationwide. The Court, in Planned Parenthood vs. Casey, reaffirmed the Roe vs. Wade ruling.

This, in turn, has launched what could be called a social war between liberals and conservatives. For example, since 1995, Congressional Republicans have attempted to pass laws banning different abortion procedures. Then-President Bill Clinton vetoed those measures, and since then, attempts at pushing those laws forward have mostly been unsuccessful. Even so, in 2003, the Partial-Birth Abortion Ban Act was passed, where a doctor may face prison time of up to 2 years, though the woman was spared from punishment.

Many states have also pushed the boundaries in regards to anti-abortion laws. North Dakota issued an act called the Personhood of Children Act whose purpose was to protect all human beings, regardless of their stage in development. In Texas, while efforts have been made to try and restrict abortion, in 2014, District Judge Lee Yeakel dismissed House Bill2, stating that the bill would place a heavy burden on women, particularly affecting those living in impoverished parts and rural parts in the state. In Louisiana, Governor Kathleen Blanco signed a ban in 2006 pertaining to most forms of abortion, although will be allowed if the life of the mother was in danger. In regards to rape or incest, she merely said she would not make decisions based on those instances.

The Problem with Anti-Abortion Laws

With the religious and societal beliefs revolving around abortion, it's easy to see why anti-abortion laws have garnered a multitude of support. Despite this however, there are long-term consequences regarding anti-abortion laws, ranging from the nonexistent impact anti-abortion laws have on overall abortion statistics, to the degradation of women's health. For example:

Shaming Those Who Have Had An Abortion

One of the main reasons why politicians enact these laws is because of their own beliefs, many of which may be quite controversial. Some have differing opinions as to when human life begins, while others take offense to specific processes as to how to handle an unwanted pregnancy. Despite this, there is no doubt an underlying stigma in regards to abortion.

Despite the many cultural and religious distinctions between groups, oftentimes, abortion is treated as a shameful thing. Many people believe that abortion violates the roles of traditional womanhood, while others view it as a threat to femininity in general. Anti-abortion laws have reinforced the belief that abortion is wrong, and is even viewed as unhealthy, both for the woman and her family. What's more, many groups, including pro-life and pro-choice groups, have capitalized on this stigma. Even more damning is the fact that women who were seen as having abortions are often treated as children, that they didn't know any better, that they were simply too naive to understand the consequences.

This, of course, has been reflected in academic studies. For example, according to The University of Chicago, many women anticipate experiencing this stigma when they first learn about an unwanted pregnancy. Approximately 58% of women feel they need to keep their abortion a secret from their loved ones. When patients see protesters outside abortion clinics, they may report feeling uncomfortable, even traumatized.

What We Can Do About It

Oftentimes, abortion has been considered an issue that affects us morally, socially, and culturally. From the various anti-abortion laws, to the shame surrounding women who get abortion and those who even support their services, there's something to be said about the way we deal with abortion in this country. Because of how politicized abortion has become, we're afraid to discuss the matter openly out of fear of ridicule or worst. What's more, because of this fear, this hinders women from learning just how these services could benefit them, whether it be psychologically or physically. This stigma has even extended to contraceptive techniques, techniques that have been used to prevent unwanted pregnancies.

To be honest, this entire situation is more than a bit hypocritical. Because while these laws are further making it difficult to get legal, safe abortions, they are also limiting options for women. A decision that should be between the woman and her doctor, or even a woman and her loved ones, is being devalued to the point where there seems to be just one side or the other. It makes the entire thing seem so…inhuman.

There should be other options that women use so they can learn whether or not the abortion would best suit their needs. There should be more information regarding different contraceptive techniques that prevent unwanted pregnancies. There should be support for those who are struggling financially with their children. There should be groups that offer women and their families support, and that don't shame them just because of what'd happened in their past. Because while it's easy for us to pass all these sorts of anti-abortion laws, it's harder for us to acknowledge the fact that sometimes, we need to deal with these issues on a personal level, not a political one.

© 2018 Robin Goodfellow

Scroll to Continue


AMK Gynae from Block 721 Ang Mo Kio Avenue 8, #01-2807, Singapore 560721 on March 12, 2019:

This indeed needs awareness for both males and females. Great article!

Tim Truzy from U.S.A. on March 20, 2018:

As you stated, the situation is personal, therefore, it is in error to assume another's relationship with their sisters. Some men actually have open honest relationships with the female members of their family. Good men should in no ways be demonized.

However, men should take more responsibility for their part, working with young men to educate them on using good judgment and contraceptives.

It is a complex topic which requires both male and female awareness.



Jean Bakula from New Jersey on March 20, 2018:

I was a senior in HS when Roe V Wade passed. Often young girls believe a young man who tells her he loves her, when he just wants sex. Then as soon as she's pregnant, he's gone. Of course, she should have known better. But our country is prudish about sex issues. So young people are not as informed as they should be.

And you can't assume your sisters never had abortions, because they never would have told you, because of this puritanical country's views. Partial birth abortions are so rare, they are almost never done. It endangers the mother and it's too late by then.

We need better sex education and birth control information for teens, and conservatives don't talk about sex with their already sexually active teens, and won't allow the schools to. So how can they learn about these topics, when they are deemed so evil? And I always wondered why there aren't more birth control methods for men?

Another group who gets abortions are women in the beginning of menopause, usually in their late 40's, who think they can't get pregnant anymore. So they go in for a "D&C", a different word for an abortion, same thing.

Until men stop wanting to dominate women, this will continue.

This was a well written piece showing both sides of the issue.

Tim Truzy from U.S.A. on March 18, 2018:

Excellent and thorough article on a topic which is controversial but at the same time, crucial to society.

I've read an article in Harper's Magazine about the state of abortions in some midwestern states, and everything you mentioned was there, in the article.

Having sisters who have never had an abortion, I often wonder what decision would they have made. I don't know.

However, I do know this - I would have been supportive regardless.

We as a society must address this on a personal level, starting with the ones who would be impacted the most as you correctly pointed out.

Thank you for a well-written and thoroughly researched article.



Related Articles