20,000 Cartons of Cigarettes - every Day!
For most of us, the thought of anything being free is a daydream, but others try to make it happen - illegally. They try to make it happen via one specific triangle in North America – on the Canada/USA border, between New York State and Ontario. They make it happen by smuggling 20,000 cartons of cigarettes across the border every day. And that’s only the cigarettes; there are no statistics for the alcohol, gas, dope, guns and people, smuggled across the border daily.
Have a look at the map and you will see where Canada and the USA have a friendly bumping contest. The Canada/US border, at nearly 4,000 miles in length, not counting the Canad/Alaska border, may be the longest friendly border on earth, but it is still a border and where there are borders there are smugglers. And this part of North America is reckoned to be a smugglers paradise.
As you can see, the USA/Canadian border tries to keep to the centre of the St. Lawrence River, but occasionally has to zigzag to avoid islands. Not only is there an international border here, there is also an abutment of two Canadian Provinces, Ontario and Quebec. As Ontario and Quebec have different laws, this is really a 4 border crossing.
Now add another complexity; into that same triangle, plonk down another Nation, a nation which is known as a ‘Jurisdictional Nightmare’ to the laws on both sides of the border - the First Nation Reserve of Akwesasne. This reserve for the indigenous Mohawks, straddles all of the borders. Part of it is on the southern side of the St. Lawrence, where it borders Quebec, and the USA. The northern part borders Canada - and is also in Canada.
Smuggling by Road, Boat, Air - and Ice?
To the 13,000 Mohawks who inhabit this reserve, the name ‘Akwesasne’ means ‘The Land where the Partridge Drums,' but locally it is known as ‘cigarette land.’
The Royal Canadian Mounted Police estimate 90% of the illegal cigarettes that cross the border into Canada, come through Akwesasne.
The locals take advantage of this border complexity on a small scale. When boaters from Ontario set off with empty gas cans, and return with those same cans full to the brim of cheaper Quebec, Akwesasne, or American gas, shoulders are shrugged, as it is accepted that the local is going to use that gas in his or her boat, and not re-sell it. Apart from which, the same boater’s ancestors probably commuted across the river to obtain or exchange goods before there were any smuggling laws, separate Provinces, or even gas.
Of course, the gas cans could be false and be filled with alcohol or cigarettes. It isn't the first time that the Border police have stopped a pick-up and found a false gas tank – full of cigarettes. Driving across the Three Nations Bridge with car trunks full of cigarettes or pickups loaded with cigarettes, is the easiest method of smuggling – it is impossible to search every vehicle crossing from the States or Akwesasne.
Another favourite method is by boat. Operating at night, with quiet motors and no navigation lights, the smugglers drop the contraband off at a predetermined spot on the Canadian side of the river. It is then picked up by another group, who distribute it to the illegal smokers.
We have seen this happen without realising it.
We’ve seen a boat dropping off cartons at an uninhabited home. As we were still puzzling over this oddity, another van pulled up, and the cartons were loaded at record speed. As the van sped off, it dawned on us - smugglers.
Frequently we see smugglers being chased down river by police launches, and often we hear gunfire when the hunting season is over. If the police launch does catch up with the smugglers boat, as long as the smugglers have jettisoned their illegal cargo, there isn’t much the police can do about it.
When the river freezes over, the smugglers find life a lot simpler. It is easier and quicker to walk across a frozen river pulling a sled loaded with smokes, than it is to boat across. Another method in winter is to load up a trailer with cigarettes and tow it across the ice by snowmobile. If the smugglers are seen and chased, all they do is unhitch the trailer; watch it speeding off into the distance - and look innocent. But even easier, when the ice is firm enough, is to load a truck up with cigarettes and drive it down onto the ice, cross the ice bridge, and drive up onto Canada.
It isn’t as if there is a vast distance between Akwesasne and Canada. The Three Nations Bridge, crosses from Canada to Cornwall Island, which is part of the Akwesasne Nation. The bridge then crosses from Cornwall Island into New York State. Pilon Island, another Akwesasne Nation island, is just over 100 metres from Canada.
One island in particular, Hamilton Island, is metres away from Canada and is connected by its own bridge.
The police forces on all borders have invested in extra equipment, such as helicopters, heat detectors and snowmobiles, in an attempt to cut down the smuggling, and they are hiring extra policemen. There have been hints recently, that the smuggling operations are being backed by international gangs, which makes a lot of sense.
A few years ago, it was discovered that the smuggling operation involved blameless Carolina tobacco firms, Montreal Mafia, Italian Mafia and Mafia/Mohawk rings, all using the Akwesasne corridor.
Recently, the police raided over 20 sites that had been under investigation for over a year, and arrested almost 30 people. During the raids, 40,000 kilos of tobacco was seized, as well as 1,000 marijuana plants; as an added bonus, $450,000 in cash was found. That should crimp the smuggling operations for a few days.
Akwesasne is the route for 90% of Canada's Smuggled Cigarettes
Where do the cigarettes come from? There are tobacco factories in Akwesasne – The Land where the Partridge Drums. According to reports (i.e. gossip) the cigarettes are of inferior quality and are made from the floor sweepings of the legal manufacturers. I must qualify the previous statement – as far as I'm aware, it isn’t illegal for cigarettes to be manufactured in Akwesasne, it is only illegal to import them into Canada without paying the tax on them.
I wouldn’t dream of suggesting that all Akwesasne residents are smugglers; only a small proportion of Mohawks indulge in the contraband business, but let me quote a remark made by a Mohawk Chief - “You also have to recognize that many in Akwesasne consider [smuggling] the exercise of their sovereignty."
Smuggling has been going on since the beginning of time, and no matter how sophisticated the law’s methods of investigation become, it will never cease. Perhaps one day we will find out that Adam smuggled the apple into the Garden of Eden.
There are snags attached to smuggling; if caught, the smuggler loses not only the cigarettes, but their vehicle, their home if it was bought with the proceeds of smuggling, all the cash in their bank balance, as well as all offshore bank balances – and their freedom. The risks are big, but people still do it.
But smugglers should be wary of the policing that has been brought in by the CFSEU………
The Cornwall Combined Forces Special Enforcement Unit (CFSEU), which is an integrated unit comprised of the RCMP, Canada Border Services agency (CBSA), Ontario Provincial Police (OPP), Cornwall Community Police Service (CCPS), Akwesasne Mohawk Police Service (AMPS) and the Ontario Ministry of Finance. CFSEU also works closely with the US Immigration and Customs led Border Enforcement Security Task Force (BEST).
You have been warned!
Drugs and Guns
There are some other points to be made about cross border smuggling – it isn’t all one way.
Marijuana (Cannabis) is legal in Canada and with the proper permit, you can grow up to four plants at home. But lots of people don’t believe in permits, or growth limitations and go slightly overboard. A few years ago a home-grown operation was discovered beside three schools in Cornwall, Ontario. Also, a derelict factory has been found to be hiding a huge marijuana grow op.
It is logical if a smuggler is taking the risk to smuggle cigarettes into Canada, that the return journey shouldn’t be wasted, so cannabis is smuggled into the States. The snag with the cigarette and cannabis smuggling is that it is almost accepted along both sides of the border with a shrug, after all, how much damage can a few kilos of cannabis and some cartons of cigarettes cause? A lot, as it happens.
The cigarettes that are smuggled into Canada are tax free and cheap as dirt. Unfortunately, it isn’t only frugal smokers who are smoking these cheap, tax free smokes. The principal smokers of these smuggled cigarettes are those who aren’t allowed to smoke at all – pre-teens and teenagers.
In Ontario there is still a prehistoric law against the law for a retailer to display cigarettes, and it is illegal to advertise outwith the store that they sell cigarettes or other tobacco products. The local service station will no doubt sell cigarettes as well as gas, but the cigarettes will be hidden, and must only be visible when being sold.
19 is the minimum age for purchasing tobacco products in Ontario, but paradoxically, 16 is the minimum age for smoking. The teenager can smoke when they are 16, legally, and only get a slap on the wrist if caught, but the person who supplied the cigarettes will be the one breaking the law. If a potential buyer looks too young, the retailer can demand proof of age, so it is difficult for a teenager to obtain cigarettes legally in Ontario.
Obtaining them illegally is so much easier.
And once the teenager or pre-teen is entwined in the tobacco smuggling link, it is oh so easy for them to become involved in the next part. The next part can be either doing some personal smuggling - of cigarettes, drugs, guns, people, or deciding to use the more lethal drugs such as heroin or cocaine. Lately, the police drug busts have been finding assault rifles along with the drugs and cigarettes. This is another worrying trend in a supposedly gun-free nation.
A $1 million dollars of Marijuana in a Garage?
A few years ago the Mohawk Police Force had another major coup when they confiscated a large amount of money, two large trailers, an SUV, two pickups...and….over a million dollars worth of marijuana, on the Akwesasne reserve of Cornwall Island.
This was a large scale Grow-op, the police spokesman said. The marijuana was caught just prior to harvesting, and lots of already packaged weed was also taken off the streets.
One of the things the growers were charged with was ‘theft of electricity’. If you are a landlord, and you lease your property, it is imperative that the tenant sign an agreement to say that they are responsible for the cost of electricity. It takes a heck of a lot of power to grow marijuana, and if you don’t have the signed waiver, and your tenant is caught with a grow-op, you, the landlord, will be liable for the power cost.
The massive uses of power, and the odour of the growing weed, are two of the principal ways of catching grow-op operators.
There was another arrest when Customs & Excise uncovered a Marijuana grow-op in a guy's garage in the middle of the Cornwall City. Altogether the plants were worth $209,000. Not a bad little business to run from your garage, if it was legal, that is.
And still they Smuggle in the 401 Corridor
A large operation snared 37 smugglers in one day lately. The criminals were smuggling guns, people, cigarettes, marijuana, and money across the USA/ Canada border.
Not only did it snare 37 smugglers, it also netted over 11 thousand cartons of cigarettes, over $50,000 Canadian, 45 kilos of marijuana. As an added bonus, the police collected 2 boats and 17 vehicles, which will no doubt be in the next police auction after the court case is finished. The smuggling was done mostly by boat, with the contraband hidden under the floorboards of fast speed boats.
The oddest part about this operation was the fact that all the 37 people were named in the local newspaper, and it caused a lot of gossip in the community. If this was still the age of neighbours gossiping over backyard fences, there would be lots of…. ‘Imagine that, and he’s from such a nice family. She’s been trouble since the day she was born; I knew she’d be in to something like this.’…. As it is, the publication of the names raised a few eyebrows and caused a lot of texting and blogging.
Normally the only information the police gives out is where the smugglers live. In this case they varied between Ontario, New York State, Quebec and Akwesasne. More surprisingly were the sex and ages of the smugglers; both sexes were involved and the ages ranged from 18 to 66.
Two homes in the city of Cornwall were also found to be marijuana grow-ops, and the homes were closed down. I’m not sure if the houses are included in police auctions, but if they are, the new owners should find the air inside the homes ‘invigorating.’
Almost as fascinating as the number of smugglers caught and vehicles seized, are the number of law enforcement agencies involved, and their acronyms. . All of these agencies have their own logos, which tend to confuse us, the innocent, law abiding citizen.
But, as long as we remain law abiding, it makes no difference to us.
Anita Hasch from Port Elizabeth on June 05, 2019:
Very interesting. I like to know what goes on in other parts of the world.
John MacNab (author) from the banks of the St. Lawrence on May 26, 2013:
Welcome again, Jess. Please keep on reading, it makes a change having someone read the hubs. I live just outside Cornwall, and I couldn't believe the smuggling when I first got here. My daughter, who used to live in Massena, was once offered a job in a cigarette factory in Akwesasne; she refused, and moved down to Washington D.C.
As I read in a newspaper article the other day, the crossing should be back where it was, and it was kinda incongruous of the natives to refuse to allow Canadian border guards to have guns, when the American ones already had them.
I find the city quite fascinating.
Jess Brazeau from Canada on May 26, 2013:
Me again. :) Your last two hubs led me to check out some of your others... This one caught my eye, as I live in Cornwall. :)
Smuggling in Cornwall is definitely a hot button issue. I've heard all kinds of ideas about how to curb it... everything from they should've put the new RCMP building down by the water, instead of way inland like they did... To even crazier things like they should just take down the bridge and make them have to enter Canada through a different border crossing further down (like Gananoque)... that wouldn't do much about them crossing over the river however, and it would hurt Cornwall's economy, as well as Massena's..
It's definitely something that Cornwall needs to take a harder stance on.. The trick though is to do it without alienating the residents of Cornwall Island.. They're not all smugglers.. The actions of a few tarnish the reputation of many... It is crazy to think though that on other First Nations Reserves throughout Canada the people live in shacks and barely have enough money to buy food, while here they're driving around in Cadillac Escalades.
It's quite the town we live in.
John MacNab (author) from the banks of the St. Lawrence on April 14, 2013:
Nell Rose: Thanks for the visit and comment Nell. It was a revelation to me when I first came here to live so close to the US border. The car searches and questions as you try to get into the USA are....time consuming. I didn't have that kind of trouble driving across into England, or Wales. I suppose that's going to change soon with Scotland looking for complete separation - daft sods.
Nell Rose from England on April 14, 2013:
They say build it and they will come, it seems the other saying, find a way in and we have cracked it, seems appropriate here! I never realised about the borders before, so many little openings that can't always be kept patroled. Interesting stuff, and fascinating read, nell
John MacNab (author) from the banks of the St. Lawrence on April 05, 2013:
tirelesstraveler: Thanks for stopping by and commenting tt. The point is cash, and lots of it. It's estimated that in that triangle alone, $300 to $400 million is smuggled across the border, that includes guns, drugs and people. Lots of the smuggling goes the other way into the US - especially the people and cannabis.
Judy Specht from California on April 03, 2013:
My mother-in-law lived on the St. Clair river for several years. You could watch people in Canada walking in their yards. All you needed was a boat to get across. My husband and his high school band had to smuggle their foreign exchange student back to the US after they had gone to Canada for a band concert . Nobody thought about her needing her passport, they put her in one of the snare drums. Until they crossed the border. I had heard stories like that , but never anything about cigarettes. What is the point?
John MacNab (author) from the banks of the St. Lawrence on March 27, 2013:
I'm glad you visited and commented drbj. There is one thing about the entrepeneurs in Akwesasne; non of them live in hovels. It's a pretty well off Reserve, and it also has its own casino. Perhaps other native (sorry; indigenous) reserves should be taking lessons from them.
When I was thinking of this article, I asked an indigenous person for some finer details regarding the smuggling and all I got was 'Are you effing crazy?' However, he did mention, without being aware of it, that it is easier when the river is frozen.