Skip to main content

To Kindle or not to Kindle? That is the Question*



Kindle Touch

Kindle Touch 3G

Kindle Keyboard 3G

Kindle DX

Kindle Fire

*(Other reading tablets are available)

I quite fancy having a Kindle. The convenience of something small and light to slip into my bag that can hold thousands of books sounds great to me, but will I miss holding an actual book? Each time I mention to friends and family that I want a Kindle I get shot down straight away “don’t do it! You’ll really miss the feel of real PAPER!” I don’t know why exactly I listen and allow myself to be talked out of it when none of them have even tried a Kindle and have no experience to base this advice on! Are they scared that books will become obsolete and eventually just fuel for fires (physically not metaphorically) and all that will remain will be a virtual library which could be lost at the push of a button? To be honest it is these conversations that have stopped me from buying one, although I do keep adding it to my Amazon wish list and my birthday is coming up so maybe I’ll get lucky.

But how much do I really want one?

I am completely addicted to my iPhone and would love to have an iPad. Hubby already has the iPad 2 and we can’t really justify having two in one household when I already have my own PC laptop to write on and my iPhone for internet browsing and game playing, so what do I really need an iPad for?

It’s pretty and does loads of stuff. I heart iPad’s. I want one just because….

Nope even though I love them I can’t justify having one and I even try to stay away from Hubby’s and let it be his alone, it was a birthday gift from me to him and not for us and if I were to get used to it I know it would "fall" into my handbag a lot.

So maybe a Kindle is a great idea for me, add to the fact that I am horrendously clumsy and it would hurt my pocket less if I were to ruin it or lose it. Let’s face it, the average hard back puts some serious weight in your handbag. But can a tablet seriously replace the look, feel and smell of a good old book? Then there’s the cost consideration, a basic kindle now costs £89 in the UK and a book can set you back anywhere between £5 and £12.99. I am an avid reader and even with the Waterstones 3 for 2 deals I can still spend a fortune every year on books. I have shelves full of books, most of which I will never read again, but I do try and lend them out to friends and family and a bundle of books have found new homes through a car boot sales. An eBookon Amazon can cost anything from a few pence (or some are free, mostly out of copyright classics) to £8 for a new release. I have a few favourite authors and like to buy their books as soon as they hit the shelves with little in the way of a discount and so the savings of a Kindle for someone like me are negligible.

Cost and Technical

The basic Kindle is affordable, but I want more than the basic. If I’m going to buy a Kindle I might as well get something a little higher up the range. The new Kindle Fire boasts a full colour screen using similar technology to the iPad and has a touch screen, full web browsing, video, music and email capabilities so it is much more flexible than the earlier models, but why have something that’s like an iPad when you can have an iPad? At $199 it is much cheaper than an iPad but doesn’t seem to offer the same bang for your buck, especially as you can now pick up a first generation iPad at a comparable price. BUT whilst you can get the Kindle software for iPad and of course read books, newspapers and magazines on the iPad using iBooks the screen is not designed for reading alone and so cannot boast that you can read a book comfortably in bright sunlight (but neither can the Fire!).

Then there’s the problem that in the UK we only have the choice of the All New Kindle and the Kindle Keyboard 3G but in the USA you can have a choice between Kindle, Kindle Touch, Kindle Touch 3G, Kindle Keyboard 3G, Kindle DX and the Kindle Fire. It is my understanding that the Kindle Fire will not be coming to the UK anytime soon as it relies on the Amazon Cloud which is currently only available in the USA. I have been reading a forum on Amazon UK about the Kindle Fire and it becomes apparent how little information there is available. Amazon has not officially explained if or when the Fire will come to the UK and the information in the forum seems to be speculation plus an odd reliable source thrown in here and there. One forum commentator wrote that he expects the iPad2 will crash in price in response to the Kindle Fire’s release as Apple will want to protect its market, but I don’t see why Apple has to worry. The iPad’s market seems secure enough and with the Kindle Fire only being available in the USA leaves the rest of the world open to the mercy of Apple and the iPad.

Flexibility and convenience

If I buy a Kindle it doesn’t mean that I am going to forgo books completely. I will still buy books and will always be delighted to receive them as gifts, but there is no doubt in my mind that the flexibility and convenience of a Kindle would do my back a great service travelling to and from work every day.

Ultimately I have to work out exactly what I want for my money and what exactly do I want to use it for and then make a decision. The Kindle so far is winning as I want something to read books on, but I would like the advantage of a colour screen and all the bells and whistles that come with the Fire but as it looks like Amazon won’t be bringing the good stuff to the UK any time soon I might stick to good old fashioned paper for a little bit longer.

Amazon Kindle Fire UK forum discussion

Would you buy a KIndle?


Colin Garrow from Inverbervie, Scotland on August 03, 2015:

I wouldn't want to choose between a Kindle and an actual book, so when I do get around to buying one, I reckon I'll still be piling up the paperbacks too.

Jasmine on April 30, 2012:

I've been thinking about this thing for I while now. It almost feels as if I wrote this article myself because that's exactly how I feel. Well, the day will come when I'll finally buy one of those things - my eyes have been on the ipad lately, but it's too expensive for me right now. I've also heard negative critics about Kindle so I can't wait to read your next hub! Voted up and interesting!

PWalker281 on April 29, 2012:

Scroll to Continue

Looking forward to it.

Nic Bouchard (author) from Devon on April 29, 2012:

I've just ordered a Kindle Touch - it arrives tomorrow - hub review to follow soon!

Nic Bouchard (author) from Devon on January 29, 2012:

It seems that you all think I should just go for it! Still on the fence I'm afraid, I'll let you know what I do and then write a proper product review. Thanks for your comments.

Priscilla from El Paso on January 28, 2012:

I don't have a kindle because of their prices but after reading what you wrote it makes me think about it more. On my android I can use it as a kindle, does that count? I also like to read physical books but I like the idea of having two or three books to read and not have to carry them around. This a great hub for a great reader like me.

stacyjwx from MA on January 28, 2012:

I absolutely love the Kindle, and every android device and tablet I have also has a Kindle app. I still love reading a paperback, but having the ability to carry so many books with me at once is what is most appealing to me about having a Kindle. Great topic!!

PWalker281 on January 27, 2012:

Girlfriend, go out and get yourself a Kindle. It sounds like you REALLY want one.

Just because you have one doesn't mean you'll never buy another "real" book again. I don't have one (yet) but I understand it's great for traveling, and as you say, you don't have to lug around a big fat book in your purse. And the ebooks are so cheap! And you can have an entire library in that slim little device. What are you waiting for? Go for it! :-)

ajaodegaard on January 27, 2012:

My dad loves his Kindle! I wasn't sure if he would right away as he is not what you would call "tech savvy", but the Kindle is easy to use and he reads all his books from there now.

mactavers on January 27, 2012:

I have a "library" of books in almost every room, so I resisted buying a Kindle until last summer. It's wonderful for instant ordering and for carrying in your bag. I do miss being able to pass a book I love along to a friend, and being able to donate it to the local library book sale. I don't see real books or Kindle as an either/or. Why not do a bit of both.

JamesPoppell on January 27, 2012:

I have a Kindle and I thoroughly enjoy it for many reasons. I also love the crisp smell and feel of a new paperback book. We are a people of technology, so the natural progression is to go digital. A Kindle is so much cheaper in the long run. Good hub. Vote up.

Related Articles