PHARMACIST SHORTAGE: IN LITERATURE
Maybe we are just dull. Maybe our mediocre medicinal milieu simply makes us an impossible profession for even the most proficient pen to portray pleasingly. The poor pharmacist! For many years America's most trusted profession, but sadly so under represented (or shamefully represented) in the great literary works. Think of your favorite book, that Cozy Classic you warm up to on winter nights. I'll bet you bucks to bookmarks, within its weathered pages, you will find a prominent place for a Doctor or a Lawyer, a Salesman or a Sailor. Your Protagonist may be a Policeman or a Parson, a Deviant youth or a Delirious Knight. From Astrologers to Zoo Keepers, these paper people come alive in literature from nearly every society and station. But where are the pharmacists? Our bookshelves are filled with Swordsmen, Sportsmen and Scientists; Kings, Culinarians and Cab Drivers. But alas, the great works of literature all appear to be well vaccinated against the infectious intrusion of the apothecary and his (apparently) uninteresting profession.
Maybe this comment on the early image of the "pharmacist" from an 1895 entry in the "Pharmaceutical Journal" might explain our rare appearance in literature:
"You are all familiar in one way or another with the apothecary of the last century. A gloomy little man in a gloomy little shop with a gloomy little helper. What mystery there was surrounding every step! His weird work with flame and flask mortar pestle and still!"
With a description like that...no wonder so few druggists have made their way into Classics!
I wish to devote this Hub to the Few and Forgotten Pharmacists who have, against all odds, made their way into the fictional works of Literature.
I WILL BEGIN WITH THE OLDER WORKS AND MOVE TOWARD THE NEWER:
ROMEO AND JULIET BY WILLIAM SHAKESPEARE
Pharmacist: "The Apothecary"
Not an especially flattering portrayal! In this Shakespeare classic, Romeo approaches the impoverished apothecary to purchase the poison needed to secure his own demise. "Ho! Apothecary" he calls. The druggist admits to having such lethal potions, and reluctantly consents to dispense them saying "Such mortal drugs I have, but Mantua's law is death to any that utters them."
In spite of laws forbidding such unethical prescriptions, this desperate pharmacist gives Romeo the poison he requests. "My poverty, but not my will, consents."
Okay..not our finest moment in Literature. Just imagine if Shakespeare had allowed the pharmacist to dispense Romeo a placebo instead! He would have been the hero! But no, he gives him the poison, and becomes a willing accomplice to Romeo's tragic death.
Romeo's life ends with him saying "O true Apothecary! Thy drugs are quick. Thus with a kiss I die."
THE APOTHECARY TURNED DOCTOR BY THOMAS BROWN
Written: 1697, also entitled "Physick lies a-bleeding," a play.
Pharmacists: Tom Gallypot, Lancet Pestle, Retorto Spatula d'Ulceroso, Jack Comprehensive
I could find very little out about this play. But a 2006 article in the British Journal of General Practice gave this description of it:
"Written in 1697, the piece highlights the greed and dishonesty prevalent among London apothecaries of the era, while at the same time showing the audience something of the hypocrisy and arrogance of contemporary physicians"
In another resource, a work entitled "A book about doctors," by John Cordy Jeaffreson, describes this play with these words: "its object was to hold up physicians as models of learning and probity, and to expose the extortionate practices of the apothecaries."
One begins to wonder about the possibility of a literary combine of sorts, secretly plotting together for the demise of the pharmaceutical profession!
PRIDE AND PREJUDICE BY JANE AUSTEN
Pharmacist: Mr. Jones
In this classic novel by Jane Austen, the apothecary (Mr. Jones), is called to the aid of Jane Bennet. His role is brief, hardly mentioned in fact. But even in this brief appearance his art seems to fall into a bit of a shadow as the sisters are convinced that "no country advice could be of any service (Chapter 8)."
Here is the context of his advice:
"The apothecary came, and having examined his patient, said, as might be supposed, that she had caught a violent cold, and that they must endeavour to get the better of it; advised her to return to bed, and promised her some draughts."
"Draughts" by the way means a "dose of liquid medicine."
Once again, it would appear, we find our doleful druggist a somewhat disregarded soul, surely the victim of some unspoken literary prejudice against our profession.
THE LOVE-PHILTRE OF IKEY SCHOENSTEIN BY O. HENRY
Pharmacist: Ikey Schoenstein
Once again the pharmacist in this short-story by O. Henry (himself a pharmacist before turning author) comes off in a poor light. The clever tale begins, however, with a witty description of the pharmacist:
"The druggist is a counselor, a confessor, an adviser, an able and willing missionary and mentor whose learning is respected, whose occult wisdom is venerated, and whose medicine is often poured, untasted, into the gutter."
But as the story unfolds, Ikey (the pharmacist) is exposed as a jealous friend who seeks to undermine the efforts of his comrade to marry the girl of his dreams. He connives a devious and deadly plan to eliminate this competitor for the female he fancies. Ultimately, however, his efforts fail. Down go all of Ikey's hopes for marrying his secret love, and down again goes the reputation of our humble profession as pharmacists.
TRAINOR THE DRUGGIST - EDGAR LEE MASTERS
Written: From the Spoon River Anthology, published in 1916
This brief poem mentions a pharmacist (the 'chemist'), and alludes to the dangers and uncertainties involved in mixing chemicals, comparing the compounding art to marriage and its potentials for disaster. Edgar Lee Masters (1868-1950) was an American poet and biographer. Himself twice married, one has to wonder if the poem has a bit of a biographical element as well.
Here is the poem:
Only the chemist can tell, and not always the chemist,
What will result from compounding
Fluids or solids.
And who can tell
How men and women will interact
On each other, or what children will result?
There were Benjamin Pantier and his wife,
Good in themselves, but evil toward each other:
He oxygen, she hydrogen,
Their son, a devastating fire.
I Trainor, the druggist, a mixer of chemicals,
Killed while making an experiment,
THE HAUNTED BOOKSHOP - CHRISTOPHER MORLEY
Pharmacist: Mr. Weintraub
I have not read The Haunted Bookshop, but it is now on my short-list of books to buy. The pharmacist appears to have a more prominent, if not more pleasant, place in this work of fiction. Christopher Morley (1890-1957) was an American journalist, novelist and poet. He was an Oxford graduate, Rhodes scholar, married and father of 4 children, and lived most of his adult life in Roslyn Estates, New York.
Here is a brief description of the Apothecary as he is introducted in Morley's novel:
"Mr. Weintraub entered the shop, a solid Teutonic person with discoloured pouches under his eyes and a face that was a potent argument for prohibition."
Though he doesn't come off with a comely appearance, at least this pharmacist seems committed to excellence within his profession. When asked about smoking, Weintraub responded "Me? I never smoke. I must have steady nerves in my profession. Apothecaries who smoke make up bad prescriptions."
This book, by the way, is in the public domain and may be read online.
ANY MORE PHARMACISTS IN LITERATURE?
I am sure there have been many more pharmacists in some of the great works of fiction. Some of my careful and more cultured readers will likely point out not a few embarrassing omissions on my part. Please feel free to add any titles to this list that you can recall. And maybe, just maybe, some author out there will read this and be motivated to put a more positive spin on this profession that has received so much ill-fated attention in literary history.
Gilbert Arevalo from Hacienda Heights, California on July 04, 2018:
Jason, I imagine authors enjoyed using the apothecary and pharmacists type characters as agents of mischief. You selected interesting examples.
Tehanuspace on December 28, 2014:
It seems that Madame Bovary is more watched as a movie than red. As written in Wiki Madame Bovary:
"Monsieur Homais is the town pharmacist. He is vehemently anti-clerical and an atheist. He also practices medicine without a license, and although he pretends to be Charles Bovary's best friend, he actively undermines Bovary's medical practice by luring away his patients and by setting Charles up to attempt a difficult surgery, which fails and destroys Charles's professional credibility in Yonville."
Jason Poquette (author) from Whitinsville, MA on March 19, 2013:
Alayne - LOVE it!!! Thanks for commenting!!
Alayne Aikens on March 14, 2013:
A Tale of Two Cities by Charles Dickens - The apothecary gives Sydney Carton two powders that when mixed together create a knock-out vapor. Sydney uses it in his plan to save Charles Darnay from the guillotine.
The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde by Robert Louis Stevenson - When the potion stops working, Dr. Jekyll blames it on the powder he gets from the apothecary. Convinced the original powder must have contained an impurity, he pleads with the apothecary to send him powder from the original batch.
David MacGuire on February 06, 2013:
Patrick O'Brian, in his Aubrey/Maturin novels has many instances of chemists compounding calomel and some other very horrifying mercury-based syphilis medications, decocting laudanum from opium and brandy and striving to make their medications as disgusting as possible, so the patient would know they were working.
Awful Poet from The Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC) (m-M)_0 = 18.41, or 48 kpc (~157,000 on August 13, 2012:
Ive enjoyed this hub as will many others , Thank you for bringing this to my attention as well as many others Ap~
L.L. Woodard from Oklahoma City on February 02, 2011:
Perhaps it is a good thing that pharmacists have escaped representation in literature. So many times character portrayal of a profession is fraught with stereotypes. Maybe you'll pen a new American classic starring a pharmacist?
Pamela Oglesby from Sunny Florida on January 17, 2011:
Interesting hubs and pharmacists have not been very well portrayed in literature. I never thought about that before.
Jason Poquette (author) from Whitinsville, MA on January 17, 2011:
Hi Jess & Annie,
I knew I could count on you both to know a few more examples! Thanks!! And yes, I have no doubt that the set was fanTAStic!!Blessings!
annie on January 17, 2011:
though not strictly a pharmacist, ben jonson's "the alchemist" is near and dear to me as we staged it in college. i believe i had the honor of prop mistress and mark may have been the stage manager. the set was fanTAStic! http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Alchemist_%28play...
Jessica on January 17, 2011:
While not a great literary masterpiece, It's a Wonderful Life contains a vivid depiction of Mr. Gower, the mourning pharmacist who, in grief for his perished son, accidentally mixes up a poisoned draught. His young assistant, George Bailey, manages to avoid delivering the toxic potion, earns an ear-boxing for his efforts, but retains Mr. Gower as one of his most loyal friends.