For years, Yvonne has been developing a sustainable homestead complete with chickens, food plants, on-site water, solar power, and more.
Here's What I Think
It's all over the airwaves, "Listerine kills germs that cause bad breath, plaque and the gum disease Gingivitis. And Cepacol advertises that it "kills germs - freshens breath and is the # 1 brand in hospitals".
But which is really the most effective at killing bacteria in the mouth?
Dentists seem to prefer Listerine and hospitals prefer Cepacol.
Which to choose? Which to choose?
I LIKE CEPACOL!
Listerine and Cepacol Claims
Each product has certain claims. Basically the biggy with Listerine is that it helps control plaque and Gingivitis. Cepacol claims to kill germs and aid in fresher breath. The label states that it is the #1 brand in hospitals.
Listerine Antiseptic Mouthwash, Cool Mint
* The American Dental Association Seal of Acceptance for helping control plaque and gingivitis.
* Listerine Antiseptic Mouthwash Helps prevent and reduce supragingival plaque accumulation and gingivitis.
* Helps prevent and reduce plaque build-up, gingivitis, and bad breath.
Cepacol Antibacterial Mouthwash and Gargle, Gold
* Cepacol Antibacterial Mouthwash with Ceepryn. Kills germs - Freshens breath.
* For daily oral care. No. 1 brand in hospitals.
* Cepacol Antibacterial kills the germs that cause bad breath.
* Cepacol Gold is the original mouthwash with a refreshing blend of cinnamon, eucalyptol and mint oils, and a cooling touch of menthol.
* For fresher, cleaner mouth, use Cepacol as an important part of your daily oral care regimen.
What the Research Says
The American Dental Association states that Listerine is more effective at reducing the effects of the Gingivitis gum disease.
In a California State Science Fair Study of the effectiveness of mouthwashes killing E. Coli Bacteria, Listerine was the least effective of the 4 mouthwashes tested, while Cepacol was the second most effective.
In a study which tested 5 different mouthwashes effectiveness against 2 bacteria, Staphylococcus epidermidis and Bacillus subtilis. "For Bacillus subtilis, the #1 mouthwash was Therasol, #2 was Scope, #3 were Rembrandt and Cepacol, and #4 was Listerine. For Staphylococcus epidermidis, the #1mouthwashes were Therasol and Scope, #2 was Cepacol, #3 was Rembrandt, and #4 was Listerine."
The Cool Mint Listerine was the most effective in killing germs.
According to a New York Times (in depth A.D.A.M.), "Mouthwashes containing cetylpyridinium (like Scope and Cepacol) have moderate antimicrobial effect on plaque, but only if they are used an hour after brushing. None are as effective as Listerine or chlorhexidine, but they may still have some value for people who cannot tolerate the other mouthwashes."
Cepacol was the second most effective of 4 mouthwashes studied in a California State Science Fair Project at killing E. Coli bacteria.
In another study, Cepacol was the 3rd most effective of the 5 mouthwashes studied against Bacillus subtilis and came in 2nd against Staphylococcus epidermidis.
Retro Listerine Comercial
My Take on the Question
Listerine is more effective against the germs that cause Gingivitis, but because of the tingling sensation and it's side effects, can not be used by some people.
Cepacol kills more different kinds of bacteria and is more effective against certain staff bacteria and those that cause bad breath, plus it is milder on the mouth and throat so it can be used by more people. Cepacol is a better gargle for sore throats and to freshen breath.
Personally I prefer Cepacol, but will use Listerine a couple of times a week for dental health, but even the milder flavor is too strong for my taste.
Your Turn! Which is Best!
Listerine vs Cepacol Mouthwash
Listerine Puts Out More Ads in the U.S. Than Cepacol
Listerine Comercial Vid
Didn't say enough? Add some more.
Ronald G Nathan, M. D. on June 25, 2020:
For sore throats Cepacol is the most effective. My dentist recommends Listerine for gum infections.
50WaysToProfit on August 03, 2012:
Thanks, I think you have a lot of good info, saved to my bookmarks!
Sabre1000 on August 01, 2012:
Our Wal-mart doesn't carry it but our local Martin's does. It is NOT discontinued.
Yvonne L B (author) from Covington, LA on March 11, 2012:
@anonymous: Perhaps, that particular drug store discontinued stocking it. Amazon.com still has several sellers with it "in stock". The Cepacol website: http://www.cepacol.com/product_mouth_lemonlime.php still shows it. There maybe a 1-800 number on the website that you could call.
You may also try calling some of the big stores like Walmart. Hope this helps.
anonymous on March 10, 2012:
my drug store,says cepacol mouth wash,has been dicontinued,for a couple of years,ive been unable to find it anywhere else.---all the others taste like,gasoline,or some diveritive of it.--i don't buy anything on the internet,but a toll free number,and credit card,and my phone i do.---but my druggist said on march 9,2012. that it was disconntinued,is that true?