This is a shocking subject and you may be wondering what constitutes psychiatric abuse. There are many that say the whole idea of psychiatry is a form of abuse because of things such as forced admission into hospital, being locked up in seclusion, dubious medications and no testing to diagnose a mental illness in the first place. Those aspects hold a long and heavy debate, so in this article I am going to look at how mental health patients can be abused by the very staff that is there to protect them.
Psychiatrists, doctors, nurses, therapists and community workers are the people who do the sometimes difficult job of caring for our mentally ill but as with any caring profession, there are good carers and bad carers. In this article I want to look primarily at abuse by psychiatrists.
There is still much discrimination and stigma shown by the general public towards those who have a mental illness. There are those people, even family members that will use terms such ‘loony’, ‘mad as a hatter, ‘cuckoo’, ‘nuts’ and ‘lunatic’.
We have made some progress over the years but not enough to dispel the whispers or alienation of mental health patients from general society. So, those who have a diagnosed mental illness are already up against the world in some respects. When people are at the mercy of the mental health profession they should be able to breathe a sigh of relief. At last someone understands them, is there for them and will keep them safe. Is this always true? I’m afraid not. Mistreatment of psychiatric patients, although not common, does happen.
Psychiatrists and Abuse
A psychiatrist is seen by the patient as a professional expert. We tend to be all trusting of such a knowledgeable professional to make us well. What isn’t evident when you first start seeing a psychiatrist is how much power and influence he has surrounding your treatment. A good patient/doctor relationship is vital to your treatment and ultimately your recovery. People who are under the care of psychiatrists are generally speaking ‘vulnerable’ people. This vulnerability is evident to a psychiatrist but a good psychiatrist will approach your vulnerability and suffering with care, compassion and dignity. Sadly, a few will exploit your position.
There are many occasions that a female patient will be alone with a trained or training male psychiatrist. Consultations with just the two of you may happen on a ward and most certainly in an out-patient capacity. You may be hearing voices, be extremely depressed and distant or in an agitated excitable state. Whatever your state at the time, the psychiatrist may inappropriately ask you questions about your sexual feelings as if it may be important to your illness. No one knows of this sexual banter because there is only the two of you in the room. You tend to answer because you trust this psychiatrist. For some it will seem confusing but you still answer because of this man’s authority as a professional. He may suggest listening to your heart as part of the consultation (because he can?). He may touch you inappropriately and I’m afraid there have been cases of actual sexual abuse to the point of rape.
According to The Psychiatric Crime Database, a study in numerous countries revealed that 10% - 25% of psychiatrists and psychologists admit to sexual abuse of patients.
All of this comes unexpectedly, is extremely shocking, can leave a patient confused and certainly mentally and physically damaged. Imagine this scenario. If there is no physical evidence of abuse, will this female patient be believed given that she has a mental illness? Will she be too scared to expose this psychiatrist for fear of reprisal and what may happen on doing so? Is she strong enough to handle this kind of abuse?
Of course there are more subtle ways that a psychiatrist can abuse a patient, male or female.
- He may unnecessarily prescribe a more powerful medication than is needed but one that he knows will give you side effects.
- He may write anything he likes about you in your notes knowing that his opinion of you will be accepted and trusted by other professionals. This may have far reaching consequences and dictate the way other professionals view you and your treatment.
- He may decide you need to be locked up for your own safety or that of others when actually it simply isn’t true.
Psychiatrists are people just like you and I and he may actually dislike you! He does however, have a code of conduct to follow and when he abuses his power or professional position and it leads to the abuse of a patient, it is a serious matter. The same applies for abuse by anyone in the mental health profession.
What to Do Following Psychiatric Abuse
Whether the abuse is subtle or very severe, if you feel it is wrong then you should muster any strength you have to expose what is happening to you. How can you go about this?
Tell Someone Immediately
Don’t allow the abuse to continue. In the first instance tell someone what has happened. You may choose a partner, family member, friend, nurse or another professional but you must share your bad experience with someone. Don’t suffer silently and of course absolutely refuse to see the abuser again.
Share the Evidence
If you have been sexually assaulted or physically assaulted in any way it is a police matter. Physical or sexual abuse usually leaves evidence and it is vital that the police see these marks of evidence promptly. Take photos of any marks on the body. If you are an inpatient when this happens and someone has a mobile phone with a camera, try to take photos of any evidence. If there is no chance of taking photos, do show someone the visible evidence, preferably a member of staff but if not perhaps you could show another patient. That said, you have every right to call the police whilst an inpatient and should ask to do so if you feel you are able.
I know that some patients may not feel they can involve the police for fear of what may happen but abuse is abuse whoever is dishing it out! Don’t forget that if you have been abused it is likely that someone else has been abused before you and may be abused in the future. Exposing the abuse you have suffered will help other patients.
Note: Restraint - If you have suffered actual and visible bodily harm as a result of being restrained, there may be cause for allegations of abuse.
What is Advocacy?
Get an Advocate
If you feel the abuse is distressing but less severe and doesn't warrant legal intervention, you should seek an advocate who can support you through a complaint process. Advocacy services are there for you when you hit problems with psychiatric care and will be able to explain the complaint procedure to you. If you feel unable to speak about certain things connected to your care, an advocate may offer to speak for you and this is accepted in the mental health services. They can attend meetings with you and support you until you feel the situation has been resolved. A peer advocate is someone who has personal experience of using the mental health service and this could be an option.
You can also contact:
- PALS- The Patient Advice and Liaison Service is available at local level nationally and is NHS based. You will usually find them at most hospitals. Their aim is to support you with any problem or concern you have with your health care. They look into any concern including the care of those with mental health problems, and can also guide you through a complaints procedure. PALS can direct you to a local advocacy service too.
- CQC – The Care Quality Commission is interested in making sure all hospital standards meet the government guidelines. You or a carer can fill in an online form to disclose any concerns about patient well-being or abuse. They can also give you information on the complaints procedure.
- The Clinic for Boundaries Studies – You can get a free first consultation for support but subsequent services will be charged. Witness also offer help with your path to recovery from the trauma experienced.
Speak out. Be brave. You have rights just as anyone else in society. If you speak out it will be helping many more from suffering needlessly. The number of undisclosed, abused mental health patients could increase the risk of suicide. I have discussed abuse by psychiatrists here but the same rights apply and the same help is there for you, regardless of who the abuser in the psychiatric system may be. You may be worried about how your mental health treatment is handled after an abuse claim but the fact is that you still have those same rights and all professionals still have a duty of care. If you find you are discriminated against in any way you can still seek support to deal with this.
This content is for informational purposes only and does not substitute for formal and individualized diagnosis, prognosis, treatment, prescription, and/or dietary advice from a licensed medical professional. Do not stop or alter your current course of treatment. If pregnant or nursing, consult with a qualified provider on an individual basis. Seek immediate help if you are experiencing a medical emergency.
meloncauli (author) from UK on May 23, 2013:
Yes...thanks L. Ron Hubbard!
Dr. Gary L. Sidley from Lancashire, England on May 21, 2013:
If you criticize psychiatry you must be a scientologist! Don't you just love it.
meloncauli (author) from UK on September 22, 2012:
No, I am not into scientology in any way, shape or form. I use personal experience and what I know to be true from working alongside mental health service users in my opinions towards mental health issues. If anything some of what I write may be understated rather than overstated.
James S. on September 21, 2012:
You're a Scientologist aren't you? Your smearing of an entire profession and your made up inflated statistics and lurid "hypothetical" scenarios all scream Scientologist. Say hi to Xenu for me.
meloncauli (author) from UK on July 13, 2012:
Hi Simone. That's the problem with psychiatric abuse. Many daren't even come forward as they feel with a mental illness no one will believe them.
Simone Haruko Smith from San Francisco on July 11, 2012:
Whaaaa? Can it really be that 10% - 25% of psychiatrists and psychologists admit to sexual abuse of patients?? I've never heard of anyone who has been abused by a psychiatrist before- and I'm glad, though it's good to know that it happens. It's better to be prepared and aware BEFORE anything bad happens.
meloncauli (author) from UK on July 07, 2012:
Hi gsidley and thanks for your comment. I totally agree. Actually, people who are suffering from a mental illness can feel very intimidated by a psychiatrist.
Dr. Gary L. Sidley from Lancashire, England on July 06, 2012:
It will not surprise you to hear that I found this hub to be very relevant and a rich source of valuable information.
Of course, there are always going to be "bad eggs" in every profession who abuse their position of trust. But as you rightly point out, I think a fundamental problem (one that provides a fertile breeding ground for abuse) is the huge power differential between the "expert" and patient. We need to move away from medical experts doctoring the minds of their patients and recognise that the only expert is the patient; after all, only he or she knows exactly what s/he is thinking and feeling.
Thanks for another astute hub.
meloncauli (author) from UK on July 06, 2012:
Thanks catgypsy. The sad fact is that psychiatrists look after our children with mental health issues also. I dread to think!
catgypsy from the South on July 05, 2012:
Important hub! Only the lowest of the low would abuse a mentally ill person, like child abusers and people who abuse animals. It's sickening. Great information on how to deal with it!
meloncauli (author) from UK on July 05, 2012:
Thanks for your comment Linda. Sadly, it's also difficult to prove unless there is visible evidence. With psychological abuse that's near impossible!
Linda Chechar from Arizona on July 05, 2012:
This is so tragic, but not terribly shocking. There will always be professionals and care givers that take advantage of the vulnerable. Thankfully there are organizations and advocacy groups that make it their business to protect those who can't protect themselves. Hopefully this will give the abused the voice they need and deserve. Thanks for bringing this to light.
meloncauli (author) from UK on July 04, 2012:
Thanks krillco. I was surprised to find little on this subject on the internet. Thanks again for the comment.
meloncauli (author) from UK on July 04, 2012:
Hi billybuc. Thanks. It is the exception to the rule of course but you're right , the more exposure the better!
William E Krill Jr from Hollidaysburg, PA on July 04, 2012:
Another great article! This information is so needed and way under exposed. Voted 'up'!
Bill Holland from Olympia, WA on July 04, 2012:
It is shocking....it is abhorrent...and it needs awareness. Great job bringing this to the light of day so others might learn from it.