Updated date:

Vegetarian 'meat' and potato pie recipe


Vegetarian meat and potato pie?

Well, not really a meat and potato pie but this is a lovely vegetarian recipe. Recently, I was writing about a crazy tradition in Yorkshire - where we're both from - which involves meat and potato pies. We both looked at each other, both thinking the same thing 'oh, meat and potato pie, lovely'.

This made me think that there must be a way to get the same flavors and 'meatiness' but using a meat-free recipe. I didn't want to use a meat substitute so this was the delicious result.Of course, I always have to make dinner as quickly as possible so I used a couple of my favorite cheat ingredients.

The pie was so very tasty and I served it with peas (always on hand in the freezer) and a very simple tomato salad - I felt that the pastry had added enough calories so chose light accompaniments.

Meat and potato pie crops up in many cultures but it's known as a traditional dish in Northern England. Mums in Yorkshire and Lancashire are experts at making a little go a long way. They'd use a cheap cut and the gravy would soak into the potatoes and the pastry - both inexpensive - making the more expensive meat go further.

The ingredients you'll need

To serve two:

  • One onion, chopped
  • Half a large eggplant, or one small one
  • Potatoes. I cheated and used a can because I was in a hurry. Of course, you can use boiled potatoes or even leftover spuds
  • Olive oil, or the oil or your choice, for frying
  • Frozen pastry - if you make your own, I take my hat of to you! If you use frozen, it needs to be defrosted first according to the directions on the packet
  • ½ teaspoon Marmite. If you hate Marmite, and I do, don't worry. The flavor goes!
  • A few black olives, chopped quite finely
  • Black pepper
  • A small pinch of sugar

Prepare the vegetables



Heat about a tablespoon of oil in a large skillet. Add the chopped onion and a small pinch of sugar. When the onions are heated through turn down the heat to low-medium. The onions need to cook slowly. Stir them occasionally so that they are evenly cooked.


The eggplant simply needs to be cleaned and chopped into cubes. When the onions have been cooking for about fifteen minutes are are soft and translucent, add the eggplant to the pan and stir well. Let them heat through and then turn up the heat; keep stirring.

Prepare the sauce and the pastry



Now that the eggplant and onions are on a high heat, keep stirring until the onion begins to brown. You don't want them to be burnt, of course, but if any smaller pieces start to turn very dark, don't worry. When the onions and eggplant are sizzling, add about a cup and a half of water. Keep some more water nearby because it's hard to tell how much will be absorbed by the eggplant so add more if necessary. The vegetables need to be barely covered. Let this boil briskly just for a few minutes. Add the finely chopped black olives.


Honestly, I can't stand the stuff. He loves it. But it adds a lot of flavor but not a Marmite-y flavor. This is too hard to describe, you'll just have to try the recipe! Add about half a teaspoon to the pan and stir well. Add black pepper too.


Simply add the canned or pre-cooked potatoes to the pan. They should be cut into bite sized pieces. Now turn the heat down and let the vegetables simmer.


At this point. our mums would line a pie dish with pastry, add the filling, and then top with even more pastry - and very delicious it was too. But I like to have pastry just on the top - pastry on the bottom too seems to be too heavy for today's palates. So I roll the pastry out and place the pie dish upside down and press. This magically cuts the pastry to the exact size of the pie dish. I cook the pastry in the halogen oven because the large oven heats up the kitchen and uses too much electricity. A toaster oven would do too.

Need inspiration? New to the idea of meat free meals? Vegetarian and considering vegan?


Use convenience foods if you want - they're convenient!

Assemble the dish


Keep stirring the vegetables occasionally while the pastry is cooking. The sauce should be reducing nicely. If it isn't simply add more heat - if it's becoming too thick, add a little water. The potatoes help the gravy to thicken.


Put the peas in a pan with a small knob of butter and heat. They don't need water because the ice surrounding the frozen peas will melt. As soon as hey're warmed through, turn the heat down to a simmer.


Of course you can serve this with any salad but be aware that if you serve it on the same plate, it will get gravy on it. Lettuce and gravy doesn't sound good to me but tomatoes are fine. I simply sliced them and drizzled with a little olive oil and fresh herbs.


Put the filling into the pie dish and top with the cooked pastry. Another advantage of not preparing the entire pie in the oven is that you can use any attractive dish, it doesn't need to be ovenproof. Call your other half into the kitchen and proudly show him the homemade pie you've made for his dinner!



Further reading

The range of vegetarian recipe books on the market is huge these days. Everyone I know - meat-eaters too - has at least one vegetarian cookbook because even those people who don't want to embrace a complete vegetarian way of life realize that the occasional meatless meal is a great healthy option. See a wonderful selection here.

Pi day!


Enjoy this recipe all year round - we do. But there's one day every year when we always have this for dinner.

As you may know, March 14th is Pi Day. This is because that date is 3 (month) and 14 (day), and I'm not mathematical enough to explain to you what pi is - I didn't pay enough attention at school - I just remember that Pythagoras bloke and the square on the hypotenuse. Nevertheless I know that pi is 3.14. But to me, Pi Day is the perfect excuse to eat pie. Why? Well, look at what 3.14 is when reversed!

© 2013 Jackie Jackson

Thanks for visiting - any comments?

Steve on January 22, 2020:

Try using a vegetable suet for the top instead of pastry it makes it taste a lot better

Jackie Jackson (author) from Fort Lauderdale on September 11, 2014:

@online4 - it's so tasty.I hope you try it!

Jackie Jackson (author) from Fort Lauderdale on July 15, 2014:

@anonymous: Yes, it's a very Northern dish - Yorkshire and Lancashire. Both were traditionally low income counties so the potato padded out the meat. I know so many Aussies who rave about Vegemite!

anonymous on July 14, 2014:

My Mum used to make meat pie with potatoes many years ago. She was from Lancashire so I guess it was a traditional dish for her to make. The vegetarian version sounds yummy but I would use Vegemite instead of marmite. I love Vegemite as all good Aussies should!

Jackie Jackson (author) from Fort Lauderdale on March 18, 2014:

@Elsie Hagley: Thank you!

Jackie Jackson (author) from Fort Lauderdale on March 18, 2014:

@TerriCarr: According to the recipe booklet that came with mine, yes. I have never done so though - because I never bake goodies due to himself's expanding waistline :)

TerriCarr on March 18, 2014:

I have never heard of table top ovens. Do they do baked goods, like cookies and brownies too?

Jackie Jackson (author) from Fort Lauderdale on March 14, 2014:

@Brite-Ideas: Thanks so much!

Jackie Jackson (author) from Fort Lauderdale on March 14, 2014:

@SteveKaye: Haha - love it,Steve!

Elsie Hagley from New Zealand on March 13, 2014:

Very nice, I like those kind of meals. Your photography of your meals are excellence, I must try to do better with my photos.

Barbara Tremblay Cipak from Toronto, Canada on March 13, 2014:

these recipe pages look wonderful, this one also! they remind me that I don't cook enough lol!

SteveKaye on March 13, 2014:

Thank you for the reminder that March 14 is Pi day. This reminds me that there was a fellow who lived in my dorm (in college) who would call people and recite pi until they hung up. Imagine hearing, "3.141592653589793238462643383279502884197169399375105820974944592307816406286208998628034825342117067982148086513282306647093844609550582231725359408128481117450284102701938521105559 . . . and so on.

anonymous on May 13, 2013:

hey! i loved it. awesome recipe!! thanks for share.

Jackie Jackson (author) from Fort Lauderdale on March 26, 2013:

@Diana Wenzel: Thanks so much - it was such fun :)

Jackie Jackson (author) from Fort Lauderdale on March 26, 2013:

@Diana Wenzel: Really they do make so much difference, and they save money too. Always good!

Renaissance Woman from Colorado on March 26, 2013:

Oh, and I meant to add in my earlier comment: Very creative... your take on Pie Day Pi Day. Nicely done!

Renaissance Woman from Colorado on March 26, 2013:

This looks very tasty. Thanks for sharing your recipe. I've never tried Marmite. It is interesting how a flavor we wouldn't normally like can be the secret ingredient that truly makes all the other flavors blend together perfectly. Thanks for introducing me to halogen ovens, too. I used to live in an incredibly hot climate where I never once turned on my oven for the reasons you stated.

Jackie Jackson (author) from Fort Lauderdale on March 26, 2013:

@knitstricken: They are a great way of saving electricity. I was late in discovering them because they are usually shown with a roast chicken inside so I thought they were intended specifically for meat!

knitstricken on March 26, 2013:

Yummy lens for Pi day! I'd never heard of halogen ovens before; interesting!

Jackie Jackson (author) from Fort Lauderdale on March 14, 2013:

@favored: Please take a good look round. I so much enjoy experimenting with vegetarian recipes. I haven't eaten meat for many years so I have a lot of meat-free recipes with more to come :)

Fay Favored from USA on March 14, 2013:

Thanks for the recipe. I see you have some other recipe articles I'd like to try also.

anonymous on March 07, 2013:

Your work is very good and I appreciate you and hopping for some more informative posts. Thank you for sharing great information to us. I feel strongly about it and love learning more on this topicwww.autobahnindustries.com/casingpipe.php