Skip to main content

Tomato Pie Recipe

Fresh Grown Tomatoes Make The Best Tomato Pie

My Tomato Pie Recipe is below

My Tomato Pie Recipe is below

A Combination of Tomato Pie Recipes

Yummy! I took the Tomato Pie Recipes from three friends and combined "this" from one and "that" from another. The Tomato Pie sure was good and easy to make! Thank you to my friends for sharing their recipes and helpful hints. I needed all the help I could get! I have included these "Helpful Hints for making your Tomato Pie" below the recipe.

I was first introduced to Tomato Pie about 12 years ago so I am really not sure how long the recipe has been around. When I first created this page, it was actually my first time to make it but I had eaten it many times before.

Here is the Tomato Pie Recipe as I made it and I hope you enjoy it as much as we do! Let me know how you make Tomato Pie. Since I first created this page, I have made this Tomato Pie Recipe numerous times and it never fails to be delicious!

The good thing about this Tomato Pie Recipe is that you can get creative and add other ingredients, too. I usually make two at a time and share one with a friend (and then wished that I had kept it for myself).

Photo: Fresh Tomato Photo made by OhMe in my kitchen. I love to put the fresh tomatoes in the window and watch them ripen. I love to pick them from the garden and eat them when they are warm from the sun.

Ready to Eat!

Tomato Pie

Tomato Pie

Tomato Pie Recipe

This Tomato Pie Recipe is a combination of several Tomato Pie recipes that my friends shared. I hope you enjoy. Be creative and share with me your own version in the guestbook below. Thanks

Ingredients for Tomato Pie

  • 4 diced tomatoes
  • 1 deep dish pie crust - 9 inch
  • 1 cup finely chopped onion (You might want to saute the onions first)
  • 1 pkg of Good Seasons Italian Dressing Mix
  • Salt and Pepper to taste
  • 1 cup mayonaise
  • 1 cup grated cheese (I use Sharp Cheddar)

Instructions

  1. Follow the directions for pre-baking pie crust. Pierce with fork on sides and bottom before baking.
  2. Dice Tomatoes and place on cookie sheet and sprinkle with salt. Allow to sit for a few minutes and then rinse and pat dry. This will keep the pie from being too runny.
  3. Layer 1/2 of diced tomatoes in pie crust and top with 1/2 of diced onions and sprinkle with 1/3 Italian Dressing Mix. Note: We only use 1/2 the pkg of Seasoning Mix just because we don't like it as strong
  4. .Repeat.
  5. Combine the remaining Dressing Mix with Mayo and grated cheese for the icing and spread over the top..
  6. Bake at 350 degrees until cheese is bubbly and golden brown.

Have you ever eaten or made Tomato Pie? - Tell me what you think about Tomato Pie and this Tomato Pie Recipe!

This is What You Need to Make Tomato Pie

Ingredients for a delicious Tomato Pie

Ingredients for a delicious Tomato Pie

Now you have your recipe, let's get the ingredients together

This Tomato Pie Recipe can be varied so don't be afraid to get creative!

Ingredients for Tomato Pie for your shopping list:

  • 3 or 4 ripe tomatoes diced
  • 1 - 9 in pie shell (of course, you can make your own pie crust if you want to)
  • 1 c finely diced onion or 2 green onions chopped,
  • 1 pkg of Good Seasons Italian Dressing Mix or a mixture of your favorite fresh herbs.

Note: Most of the time I just use 1/2 pkg,Salt and Pepper,1 c mayonnaise,1 c grated cheddar cheese. I must say that I like my Tomato Pie better than most I have tasted in restaurants.

Almost Ready for the Oven!

This one will be ready for the oven soon.  Not yet, though.  You have to add what I call "the icing"!

This one will be ready for the oven soon. Not yet, though. You have to add what I call "the icing"!

Next, you will need to prepare your tomatoes and onions for your Tomato Pie

3 tomatoes if they are large, 4 if they are smaller

While your pie crust is pre-baking,do the following:I always peel my tomatoes before dicing but this is a personal preference. I have never tried this Tomato Pie Recipe with canned tomatoes but may have to do that this winter. I think it would be great with the canned seasoned diced tomatoes. I know that many people don't peel their tomatoes but we do.Spread your diced tomatoes on a baking sheet,salt and let sit for several minutes.Then rinse and pat dry with a paper towel.

Note: This helpful hint was on my friend's recipe that she got from Grits and Groceries Restaurant Website

Layer 1/2 of the tomatoes topped with1/2 of the onions (some people like to sauté their onions first) and sprinkle with1/3 of the Italian Dressing Mix, Add another layer with the remaining tomatoes and onions and sprinkle that with 1/3 of the dressing mix.One of my friends likes to add extra Oregano,Basil, and other spices.

The Tomato Knife - Do you have a Tomato Knife? - Slice your tomatoes using a good Tomato Knife

Now for the Icing of your Tomato Pie

Spread this topping all over the top of the pie, add salt and pepper

Ice with the mixture of grated cheese,mayonnaise and remaining dressing mix.I have found that Sharp Cheddar is betterfor cooking than Extra Sharp.The Extra Sharp seems to get grainy. My sister made it using the shredded 3 cheese pkg and said it was very good. That's a good thing about this recipe. You can be creative.

Scroll to Continue

Bake your Tomato Pie at 350 degrees until Golden Brown - Cheese should be bubbly and onions cooked

tomato-pie

Photo Above: Someone Got Into My Pie

Mine was still a little runny but still tasted great. My hubby said, "That's right tasty!" You can see a section of the done pie looks a little different. That is because I cut it before it was completely done. I just had to go ahead and eat the cut portion! Sorry about that! I guess the saying "Patience is a Virtue, is true!"

A different Tomato Pie Recipe found on Cooking Up A Story - Cooking Up A Story is a show about people, food and sustainable living

Thank you to Rebecca Gerendasy for giving me permission to add this video to my lens. Please visit Cooking Up A Story Cooking Up a Story, strives to build communities around the many important and interconnected issues that involve food and sustainability. We produce three shows about people, food, and sustainable living: Stories consists of documentary shorts about farmers, artisan producers, and others; FOOD NEWS features interviews with experts on the science, politics, and culture of food; and Cooking Fresh showcases food enthusiasts as they demonstrate how to cook fresh seasonal foods.

There are many versions of Tomato Pie Recipes

Italian Tomato Pie

  • Italian Tomato Pie
    Check out this Italian Tomato Pie recipe and Charlino has a printable Recipe Card on this page just for you.

Tiny Tomato Tarts Recipe on Southern Living - Southern Living has some great Recipes

This Tiny Tomato Tarts Recipe is so good and easy. It calls a can petite diced tomatoes so it can be made year round. These are wonderful appetizers. My friend brought some of these to our home for appetizers are we all enjoyed them very much.

Tomato Tarts Recipe

Tomato Pie by Donna Preeper

tomato-pie

Friends shared their Tomato Pie story and photo!

Thank you, Donna and Earl Preeper

"Hi Nancy Thanks for the link to the tomato pie recipe. We have lots of tomatoes and that was a perfect recipe to use some, plus I had never tried a tomato pie. I did not have a pkg of the Italian dressing mix, so I used fresh basil,thyme and rosemary from my herb garden. I also watched the video from your link(cooking up a story) and used the caramelized onion idea to top the pie. That made it very tasty. I then just top the onions off with mozzarella. Thanks again for the link. Donna

PS we ate the entire pie except for 2 slices! Em em good"


Note: Earl is the owner of Alpha-Dog Dog Obedience Training and he has been working with us and our Bulldog, Bruno! We sure have learned a lot.

A Facebook Friend Shares Her Tomato Pie Photo - Thank you, Lynne!

It's been fun to read the comments from Facebook Friends who have used this recipe or one very similar.

It's been fun to read the comments from Facebook Friends who have used this recipe or one very similar.

I hope you and your family enjoy this Tomato Pie as much as we do! - I am always ready for the tomatoes to ripen in the garden because this means that it is tim

Will it be today? I sure hope so!

Will it be today? I sure hope so!

There is nothing like friends who share from their garden! - Thank you!

tomatoes, egg plant, okra

tomatoes, egg plant, okra

Want to share your Tomatoes or Tomato Pie Recipe?

We have always been so fortunate to have friends who share their garden with us. We usually have a small garden but never turn down anything that anyone wants to give us.

I would love to hear how you make Tomato Pie as well as other Tomato Recipes.I have never made this in the winter with canned tomatoes but may have to try it this winter and will let you know how it taste. Please sign my guestbook.

Tell me about your favorite recipe using fresh tomatoes - Did you like this Tomato Pie Recipe?

Nancy Tate Hellams (author) from Pendleton, SC on March 03, 2018:

Yes, I do love our tomato knife and didn't know there was such a thing for many years.

Connie Rasbury on March 03, 2018:

Now my mouth is watering. I make a tomato pie very similar to yours but have never tried the dry Italian dressing. I like the way you make the icing. I need to get one of those tomato knives.Thanks for the tip and all the great recipes.

Susie Lehto from Minnesota on September 12, 2016:

Joan posted a link to this recipe on Facebook, Nancy. I have wanted an excellent tomato pie recipe for a while, now I believe I have one to use for the harvest of tomatoes this year.

amandascloset0 on April 24, 2014:

I can't wait to try this! Looks great!!

acreativethinker on March 02, 2014:

This tomato pie looks delicious! Great photos and lens. Thanks for sharing. Take care :)

Merry Citarella from Oregon's Southern Coast on February 19, 2014:

Never tried one, but this looks so good. The photos of the fresh tomatoes make my mouth water. I'll have to add this to my recipe list.

acreativethinker on October 29, 2013:

Looks simply delicious. I like using fresh tomatoes on my homemade pizza. Thanks for sharing. Take care :)

flycatcherrr on August 12, 2013:

I've never heard of tomato pie before, but it looks tasty! With this year's really good crop of tomatoes, I will most certainly give it a try - thank you!

InfoCoop on April 01, 2013:

Tomato pie has never sounded good to me but your pictures make it look so yummy. I might just have to give it a try!

RaintreeAnnie from UK on March 23, 2013:

Your tomato pie recipe sounds delicious!! I would have voted I have never had it but it sure sounds great - and I want to! We love tomatoes and this sounds like a new dinner for us :) Thank you

KonaGirl from New York on March 14, 2013:

I just love fresh tomatoes off the vine and this tomato pie recipe sounds heavenly! I have never had one before. Pinning it so I can make it when tomatoes are back in season. *Squid Angel Blessed*

oranagade on March 14, 2013:

Oh, my does this look good. You made me hungry!

Nancy Tate Hellams (author) from Pendleton, SC on March 10, 2013:

@Jogalog: Thanks for visiting, commenting and that great blessing. I hope you will get back with me after you have tried this recipe. I would be interested in knowing how you liked it.

Jogalog on March 10, 2013:

I love using fresh tomatoes and they go so well with cheese so I'm sure this is really tasty.

anonymous on January 30, 2013:

I have never tried this before, it looks quite good.

ohcaroline on January 26, 2013:

This is a new one for me. It looks yummy...but I can't imagine what it would taste like.

GreenerDays on January 10, 2013:

Looks yummy! I definitely want to try out this recipe.

Peggy Hazelwood from Desert Southwest, U.S.A. on October 24, 2012:

Back to refer to this. My tomato pie is in the oven. Smells so good in here! Thanks again for this great go-to recipe.

Funkysi on October 18, 2012:

Sounds good. I will try this recipe.

getmoreinfo on October 06, 2012:

I like this Tomato Pie Recipe

worldflashpacker on September 16, 2012:

Never thought of putting my favourite red fruit in a Pie. Delicious recipe.

Peter Badham from England on September 16, 2012:

Thanks for visiting my 'essential kitchen food ingredients' lens and I'm glad you liked it. I've never tried tomato pie but yours is on my to do list.

Peter Badham from England on September 11, 2012:

Hello ohme, You have a great lens! Tomato pie seems to be coming into fashion in England, good job!I have set up a brand new lens which tells you the basic core ingredients for different cooking styles, ie, Southern, Indian, Spanish etc. I have personally chosen you as one of the contenders in a little competition Im doing. Under each list is a poll asking if you can think of recipes and dishes to create, using some of the ingredients, plus others of your own ingredients, ie meat, fish pasta etc. There are different tasks for each section, ie a Vegetarian Chinese recipe, or a Chicken Curry recipe etc.You can then put your recipe name in the voting poll further down with a link to the recipe (which might be on your lens) creating more traffic for you. Once I have received the first 10 links and recipes I will start a 15 day countdown. The top 3 voted for recipes at the end of this period will be placed as a permanent link on my Lens.I have posted the first link Gordan Ramsays Chicken Curry, lets see if the public like one of your recipes more than his.I do hope you would like to participate in my little competition. The Squidoo lens is http://www.squidoo.com/essential-kitchen-food-ingr...

Laraine Sims from Lake Country, B.C. on September 07, 2012:

I've got tons of tomatoes right now and I remembered that you had a recipe for tomato pie that looked interesting. Now I am a SquidAngel I can bless this lens. **Thank you for the recipe**

nolinel lm on September 03, 2012:

It looks divine, going to try it next week...

Nancy Tate Hellams (author) from Pendleton, SC on August 29, 2012:

@dpgibble: Glad to hear about your contact button. I did send you a message the day it went live but will be back to visit. Thanks for stopping by here.

Nancy Tate Hellams (author) from Pendleton, SC on August 29, 2012:

@Dusty2 LM: Sharing one's garden goodies is a common thing in our neck of the woods and I sure am glad.

raisingsmallsouls on August 27, 2012:

This looks scrumptious! I wish someone would make it for me- yum!

Dusty2 LM on August 27, 2012:

Very interesting lens. I have had tomato pizzas but never tomato pie. The way you describe the tomato pie who could resist from trying to make the tomato pie. I especially like the story about the produce co-op with your friends and neighbors. You don't find that happening that much today. Thank You for sharing and stopping by my peach pie lens and giving it a "thumbs up". I appreciate it.

dpgibble on August 26, 2012:

Tomato pie is our family favorite since my wife started making it last season. My contact button is now active.

Frischy from Kentucky, USA on August 26, 2012:

I have never heard of this before, but it does sound yummy.

anonymous on August 24, 2012:

Tomato Pie Recipe looks amazing, I should really try it sometime.

aishu19 on August 23, 2012:

I have never had tomato pie before. but I would love to try it sometime

anonymous on August 21, 2012:

I've only had tomato pie once in my life and I loved it. I had it at a restaurant called Our House (now closed) in my hometown of Selma, Alabama. The dish was included in the Alabama Tourism Bureau's list of 100 Places to Eat in Alabama before you Die. Actually, I've not heard of tomato pie again until I discovered your lens. I'll have to get my sister-in-law (the best cook in our family) to make me one from your recipe. Your photos make my mouth water. All the best.

inspirationz on August 20, 2012:

never had tomato pie before but it sounds very interesting indeed! I was a bit concerned what I skim read and saw "ice your pie"... and thought "whaa?? ice it with icing sugar??" but then I saw "ice it with cheese" and all was right with the world again ;) hehe awesome lens - i might come back to this one to try the recipe!

MayaIxchel on August 19, 2012:

Okay, I had never heard of tomato pie, but now I think I will have to give it a try. We always have loads of fresh tomatoes here! Thank you so much for sharing! Greetings from 'the land of eternal spring'!

DesignSpace on August 19, 2012:

Ooh, interesting recipe, I'll have to try it out...

Michey LM on August 18, 2012:

I eat a lot of tomatoes, as I like them but I never create a pie until your lens convinced me... I try it and it is delicious. Thanks Blessings!

anonymous on August 18, 2012:

Returning to sprikle angel dust over your delicious tomato pie, you had my mouth watering...again!

soaringsis on August 16, 2012:

I love tomatoes and must try this recipe. Thanks for sharing.

norma-holt on August 16, 2012:

Wonderful presentation of something that looks urresistable, My garden usually grows wonderful tomatoes and I share everything with neighours. Maybe I will now share this recipe, Featured on Blessed by Skiesgreen 2012-2 and also on Squidoo Cooking Cakes Recipes. Hugs.

rawwwwwws lm on August 15, 2012:

BTW Thank you sharing, appreciate it.

rawwwwwws lm on August 15, 2012:

Passed by this lens before, but came back for a revisit for the recipes!

sarasentor lm on August 13, 2012:

I must say that your lens is delicious.

olmpal on August 06, 2012:

I have to try this recipe! Sounds delicious!

Chazz from New York on August 05, 2012:

This is the first I've heard of tomato pie and I'm heading out to pick some tomatoes to give it a try - looks and sounds wonderful!

Nancy Tate Hellams (author) from Pendleton, SC on August 03, 2012:

@Lubicz: Let me know how it goes if you try it

Nancy Tate Hellams (author) from Pendleton, SC on August 03, 2012:

@VeseliDan: Thanks so much for the visit and the blessing!

Nancy Tate Hellams (author) from Pendleton, SC on August 03, 2012:

@Diva2Mom: Let me know if you try it. I would love to add your pie picture here

Nancy Tate Hellams (author) from Pendleton, SC on August 03, 2012:

@CristianStan: I guess it is just for show and not for reading. lol

Nancy Tate Hellams (author) from Pendleton, SC on August 03, 2012:

@ellies lm: Thank you for sharing this recipe!

Nancy Tate Hellams (author) from Pendleton, SC on August 03, 2012:

@anonymous: Oh wow, I would love to have a greenhouse full of tomatoes. Thanks for dropping by. If you make it, take a picture and I will post it here

ellies lm on August 03, 2012:

Just sent your recipe to a Facebook Friend.

anonymous on August 01, 2012:

I had never thought about making tomato pie Nancy, but this recipe will come in handy soon - I have a greenhouse full of tomatoes :)

eccles1 on July 31, 2012:

I love tomatoes but I have never had a tomato pie!

Thamisgith on July 26, 2012:

I've never even heard of tomato pie - but it looks mouth watering!

Lubicz on July 26, 2012:

Wow! an actual tomato pie! Got to try that! Big thanks for the recipe.

VeseliDan on July 25, 2012:

Tomato pie sounds delicious! I will surely try out your recipe! *blessed*

CristianStan on July 25, 2012:

I like the recipe apron idea, but how would I read it while wearing it? I can't make sense out of that part.

Diva2Mom on July 21, 2012:

Absolutely! I've never heard of Tomato Pie, and I love the fact that this recipe is healthy and looks so yummy. Gott try this unique recipe. What a creative lens to come up with a unique tomato recipe! Brilliant! Love your lens! God bless.

hartworks lm on July 20, 2012:

We're looking to have a great batch of tomatoes this year, turning color in the garden... gotta try this!

happynutritionist on July 19, 2012:

I tend to use fresh tomatoes in salad, but you have enticed me to try this, it looks like a perfect way to use tomatoes this time of year when the prices are down and if the gardens are overflowing where you live.

rawwwwwws lm on July 18, 2012:

I have never eaten tomato pie, but after your lens I would love to try out the recipe! IT looks really yummy. Thank you for sharing such a wonderful lens about tomato pie, I appreciate it greatly!

peggygallyot on July 18, 2012:

I too would like to try a tomato pie. Never had it at all.

tomazg on July 18, 2012:

I'm not a fan of tomatoes but I would still like to taste one of tomato pies. I'm sure they are quite delicious.

Faye Rutledge from Concord VA on July 17, 2012:

Mmm, this looks so good! :)

piedromolinero on July 13, 2012:

Sounds and looks delicious. I never had tomato pie, but I will try it.

Mary Norton from Ontario, Canada on July 10, 2012:

I haven't yet tried it but it look really good.

anonymous on July 07, 2012:

Haven't made any yet but will have to give this one a try. Always looking for something different. And this will use up some of my home grown tomatoes too.

ansruthi on July 07, 2012:

yummy lens.... i want to taste it?

Heidi Vincent from GRENADA on July 04, 2012:

I have never tried a tomato pie but I will now since it's great to have a new recipe for tomatoes.

Joan4 on July 04, 2012:

I made this pie tonight and it is fabulous!!!!!!!!! I did use a cup of 3 cheese shredded cheese instead of cheddar.........will try with cheddar next time, but it was delish!!!!!!!!

Dianne Loomos on July 04, 2012:

I'm glad I ran across this tomato pie recipe again. It sounds so good and I'm hoping to get tomatoes from my garden this year!

BarbaraCasey on July 04, 2012:

I love learning new stuff like this. I'd never heard of tomato pie before today... but now I'm wanting to try it.

ArthurF LM on July 04, 2012:

That looks amazing!

GypsyOwl2 on July 01, 2012:

Stopping by to read this tomato pie recipe - I think it's easy enough for me to do!

anonymous on June 28, 2012:

Can't believe it, but I just had tomato pie for the first time about a month ago. Wow! Loved it! I'm going to make your recipe, Nancy, with some tomatoes from my little garden. Can't believe you didn't put basil in your recipe!

Pam Irie from Land of Aloha on June 27, 2012:

Honestly, I just love to eat a tomato picked right out of the garden with a salt shaker in one hand. :)

jballs6 on June 24, 2012:

I love tomatoes, this recipe sounds simply yummy!

JoshK47 on June 23, 2012:

Sounds interesting - blessed by a SquidAngel!

mumsgather on June 18, 2012:

Your pie looks amazing and delicious! I've never tried tomato pie before but I think I will now.

Camden1 on June 17, 2012:

I've never had Tomato Pie, but it sounds yummy.

FashionMommy on June 15, 2012:

It looks delicious. I will have to try making this one of these days.

microfarmproject on June 14, 2012:

Wow, this looks delicious. I grow lots of tomatoes in the summer. This would be a great way to use some of them. Thank you!

anonymous on June 14, 2012:

Can't wait to make tomato pie. I have have fresh tomatoes out of my garden, Right Now!Kim

ForestBear LM on June 12, 2012:

Sounds yummy, will have to try it! Thank you for sharing

mikes-cool-stuff on June 12, 2012:

Wow, tomato pie! I guess you make pie from almost anything. Nice and interesting lens. I never heard of this. Thanks also for dropping in and liking and commenting on one of my lenses.

CruiseReady from East Central Florida on June 11, 2012:

Sounds delicious, and I really like that you took several recipes and made your own from them... sometimes those are the best kind!

Michey LM on June 06, 2012:

Come back to confess that I never did tomato pie (souffle) so all has been new to me, I tried and was delicious.Thanks

Aboutlowercholesterol on June 05, 2012:

Yummy yummy yummy - I love tomotoes and so these are going to be tried out for sure!

skylander on June 03, 2012:

Was a bit sceptic about a tomato pie! Tried the recipe and loved it. Awesome lens.

Peggy Hazelwood from Desert Southwest, U.S.A. on June 03, 2012:

Back again for your great recipe. I always forget from the computer to the kitchen to layer things so mine is a mixture, and it always tastes great. Thanks!

Dianne Loomos on June 03, 2012:

I just planted my tomatoes yesterday. Hoping for a good crop so I can make things like your Tomato Pie Recipe!

sammyaddams lm on June 02, 2012:

I have never tried tomato pie before, sounds delicious and easy to make too, can't wait to try it out.

CherylsArt on May 29, 2012:

I hadn't heard of tomato pie before, but it does sound appetizing. I like making home made spaghetti sauce with fresh tomatoes.

elizabethknows lm on May 25, 2012:

this looks really good.. I am gonna try it.

Millionairemomma on May 22, 2012:

Oh my goodess. I was so delighted to come across this lens because I've never seen or heard of it before. Kind of looks like a yummy pizza to me. I will bookmark it to try. Thank you very much for sharing it with us.

Michey LM on April 23, 2012:

I never did tomato pie but you convinced me to do it with your combined recipe

pawpaw911 on April 13, 2012:

I've never had it. Sounds good though.

anonymous on March 28, 2012:

Many times the research is worth the effort, lucky to have created this recipe which is yummy.

Related Articles