Updated date:

KitchenAid Pasta Press And Pasta Roller

KitchenAid Pasta Gadgets - Pasta Press or Pasta Roller Attachment?

Like many other serious cooks, a few years ago, I gave in and bought a KitchenAid Artisan Stand Mixer when I couldn't resist the price at Costco. Now my dilemma is this - do I prefer my old KitchenAid Pasta Roller attachment or would I rather have the KitchenAid Pasta Press attachment I just discovered?(Also known as the Pasta Extruder)

How does each shape up and what is the ease of use with each attachment?

I have been going over the pros and cons for a couple of weeks now since I saw the new Pasta Press attachment advertised at Williams and Sonoma and decided to do some research to try to make my decision before purchasing yet another kitchen gadget!


Photo: Audrey Kirchner

Photo: Audrey Kirchner

Thoughts on KitchenAid Pasta Attachments

I can truly speak from experience because I have used the KitchenAid Pasta Roller many times and have made a variety of pasta doughs with it. It's a great little machine. You attach it to the front of the KitchenAid stand mixer and after making the dough, you set it on different settings or add different attachments and make anything from lasagna noodles to spaghetti noodles. I have made various kinds of doughs such as semolina pasta or spinach noodles. There are many delicious recipes for pasta dough that come with the attachments or you can find countless more on the Internet.

You can also buy the Pasta Excellence Kit which is a wee bit pricey but....not only do you get the benefit of making your own pasta dough...now you can use the cutters to cut any size dough you like. You can also use the Ravioli Maker to make what else? Ravioli!



The Pasta Press definitely caught my eye on Williams and Sonoma. On looking at the video, for the Pasta Press, I couldn't believe the convenience of making the dough and simply feeding it in by little pieces through the tube. Once you've selected what kind of pasta you want with the appropriate plate, the noodles come out already formed to the right thickness and for that particular noodle. You easily cut to them size with the attached cutter handle.

Again, the Pasta Roller is a great attachment to have for the KitchenAid mixer. It is more labor intensive but then you can make such things as tortillas, lasagna noodles, thin crust pizza dough and perogies.

Then there is of course the Pasta Cutter attachment. Once you have made your dough and rolled it to the desired thickness with the Pasta Roller, you can cut the dough into angel hair pasta or fettucini - or anything in between. This is sold separately or comes as part of the Pasta Excellence Kit!

Coming back to the KitchenAid Pasta Press, this attachment will make 6 different kinds/sizes of pasta noodles already formed. While I would still need my Pasta Roller for making lasagna, I think I would enjoy making pasta noodles quickly with the Pasta Press. The 6 kinds of pasta noodles you can make are:

  • Small macaroni
  • Rigatoni
  • Bucatini
  • Spaghetti
  • Fusilli
  • Large macaroni

First you select your pasta type and then insert the appropriate plate inside the attachment. The attachment comes with 6 plates for the above 6 types of pasta. The plates are stored in a case on top of the pasta attachment. This attachment also comes with a wrench/pusher for the tube, a cleaning brush and complete instructions with recipes for pasta.

Of course, don't forget that you will need pasta drying racks as well! They come in many different varieties and sizes and work really well for the finished product.

Now where was I? Oh yes, comparing the KitchenAid pasta attachments and trying to decide if I should purchase another!


Summing Up KitchenAid Pasta Attachments

You know - after viewing the videos and reading all about all of these attachments, I am in a bit of a pickle! I think I need all of them and that was not what I started out to accomplish here!

However, I did learn more about the Pasta Roller attachment for my KitchenAid mixer which I already have. I also learned about some new things I can make with it such as homemade tortillas!

I also learned that there is a Pasta Excellence Kit that somehow I did not know about (my Pasta Roller was a gift).

I did not know there was a Ravioli Maker! You can of course use the Pasta Roller attachment to make long sheets for ravioli dough and then assemble them on cookie sheets easy enough. I have made ravioli all the away from scratch without a dough roller and it was fabulous homemade!

I also learned that the Pasta Cutter can be used to cut the pasta dough from fettucini size to angel hair size in minutes rather than cutting it by hand! And you can buy it separately without the Ravioli Maker.

And last but not least, I learned more about the Pasta Press that will make 6 different kinds of pasta in perfect shapes such as macaroni, fusilli, and rigatoni. Now if only they had an attachment for farfalle or bow-tie pasta! Hmmm....maybe they will come up with one of these in the future....or I should write and suggest it!

I imagine you can see where I'm going with this. I may not be able to make a choice now and may end up with ALL the pasta attachments. Actually, it would not be a bad investment since I already have the mixer, eh? And I do make pasta regularly such as lasagna, macaroni, fusilli, angel hair and fettucini - so I would have plenty of uses for all my KitchenAid pasta attachments!

I only need more storage space to house all of my attachments!

Whichever KitchenAid attachment you buy though, I have found them to be totally durable, easy to clean and use, and have never had one problem with any of mine.

It is a wonderful invention to have a great mixer and then be able to use it for so many other things, such as kneading bread, making pasta, grinding meat, etc.

In a world of gadgets, I'm thinking KitchenAid kitchen gadgets rock!


Pasta Press or Extruder Making Rigatoni

Making Fettucini with KitchenAid

KitchenAid Ravioli Maker Demo

KitchenAid Dough Roller

KitchenAid Pasta Rollers

Hubs on KitchenAid and Homemade Pasta

  • KitchenAid Stand Mixer: An Investment For Your Kitch...
    A stand mixer is an incredibly useful tool in the kitchen when it comes to cooking and baking. Trying to find the best one for you can be difficult as there are many different brands, models and bells and...
  • Thinking of buying a KitchenAid Mixer
    Tough dough or sticky batter will demand the services of only the toughest and strongest mixer. You might have a nightmare trying to blend in the ingredients with a low power mixer or using something like a...
  • How To Find The Best Deal On Kitchenaid Mixers
    How To Get The Best Deals On Kitchenaid Artisan MixersKitchenaid has been around for a long time producing quality products and is one of the most widely known brand names on the market today. Though many...
  • The KitchenAid Mixer
    The basic design of the kitchenAid mixer has been around for decades. It does a great job of the mixing most families require of this appliance. Unlike the more popular, in the past, Sunbeam Mixmaster, the...
  • 12 Super Fast, Cheap and Easy Pasta Recipes
    Think you cannot cook, or you are too busy to cook? Out of ideas? Try these 12 fast and easy pasta main dishes. Each recipe uses only 2 to 5 ingredients, is quick to prepare, and is tasty.
  • Homemade Noodles
    Homemade noodles are so good: soft, tasty, and satisfying. Fresh pasta offers a completely different texture and taste experience. Learning the art of pasta making means adding a little something different to the menu.
  • All about Homemade Pasta
    Light, thin sauces are best paired with thin pastas, such as angel hair or thin spaghetti Chancy sauces are best paired with pastas with holes or ridges, such as ziti, rotini Heavy sauces are best...
  • How To Make Homemade Pasta
    Making homemade pasta is not nearly as difficult as many may think! The process is only slightly time consuming, but produces a delicious result you can't get from a box! Ingredients: 2 1/3 cups all-purpose...
  • The secrets of homemade pasta
    If you want to prepare homemade pasta than is better to choose the
  • Homemade pasta recipe. It's easier than you think, a...
    Make your own pasta for a weeknight supper A lot of people are intimidated by homemade pasta. They imagine it as needing a lot of specialized equipment and a high level of skill. While it's...
  • How to Make Homemade Ravioli. All You Need is a Roll...
    You don't need a pasta machine to make ravioli from scratch! All you need is a little time and energy. Learn how to make homemade ravioli using just a rolling pin and use your creativity for fillings and sauces.

Join Hubpages

Do you like writing too? Do you want to share your thoughts and make money at the same time? If so, you have come to the right place! Hubpages is a great place to write! You can make money in four ways - Adsense, Amazon, Kontrera, and Ebay. Furthermore, Hubpage members are friendly and willing to help you learn the ropes. Sign up today at Hubpages for free!

Comments

Audrey Kirchner (author) from Washington on July 08, 2011:

Slaquer - you raise some interesting points - I think though from my own experience, you just have to try the pasta recipes....I've even made a well in the flour and then rolled and rolled and rolled - literally from scratch, hung my pasta up and let it dry.

It all has to do with where you live (humidity), the flours that you use (semolina or unbleached) and your machine - or by hand. You just have to decide based on your own expertise and your own environs what tastes the best to you.

Having made everything from cannelloni from scratch (that was the rolling method - oy vey that killed me) - to egg noodles (again with the rolling but not so difficult), then gnocchi and then lasagna with the roller attachment on my mixer...I'd really think that this little spit it out device would be pretty cool.

Everything manmade doesn't mean it's better for us - it just means that it's more convenient and I think globally we've all forgotten how to just get out a bowl and make something. Gadgets and machines are only as good as we the operators make them I suppose, eh?

I'm personally going even further along to be self sufficient and "green" by making everything I can from scratch including bread. It's not that difficult - but you just have to figure out what recipe works for you and where you live I guess!

Thanks for such an insightful comment - made me think!

slaquer on July 08, 2011:

Most brands of commercial pasta are apparently made with the same flour. I suppose that variations in texture and elasticity result from difference in process. The aging kneading, and consistency of the dough are probably carefully worked out. Some producers will optimize quality, others, something else The home extrusion process will surely require a softer dough than the roller process. Question: can the extrusion process give a product equal to the roller? I don't think we can use the commercial products as a guide because their extrusion presses probably have massive horsepower allowing them great freedom in dough consistency.

So, let's address quality, and put aside convenience for a moment. How to make great pasta, better than Dececco, better than Barilla? Extruder or roller?

Audrey Kirchner (author) from Washington on March 16, 2011:

Thanks kitchenaid for dropping by - I actually have the bigger one because I found it at Costco - can't say how many hundreds and hundreds of times I use it!

kitchenaid on March 16, 2011:

Anyone likes to cook, make cakes, knead dough, batter on different ingredients, would really love it to have the KitchenAid Stand Mixer KP26M8XMC on their hands. The Mixer is said to have great ability and comes in bigger size and also bigger bowl to make sure users can really find the device beneficial in accommodating big amount of cooking dough.

Audrey Kirchner (author) from Washington on December 14, 2010:

HKF - Thanks for stopping by and the great comment - I will have to try my roller again as your description of using it is making me crave homemade pasta!

hellokittyfan from RI on December 13, 2010:

I actually have all the pasta attachments you talk about, but I only seem to use the roller set. I have used the extruder press rarely, maybe once when I first got it as a gift. I have used the roller set to make ravioli, fettucine, whole wheat pasta, and even for wonton skins!

Audrey Kirchner (author) from Washington on August 17, 2010:

Thanks KPCWriting for stopping by and for the kind comment.

Audrey Kirchner (author) from Washington on August 12, 2010:

Thanks for buzzing by, Micky - it helps me to think of all the angles before I think of purchasing! Good for the brain, too!

Micky Dee on August 12, 2010:

Wow! Bunch of work and a bunch of homework here! Great job as always Audrey!

Audrey Kirchner (author) from Washington on August 09, 2010:

Glad to be of service, Crewman6 - uh of course for Monique's sake! ha ha I love anything to do with pasta so this is right up my alley - or one of them! Thanks for stopping by!!

Crewman6 on August 09, 2010:

Audrey, Monique is a kitchen-gadget fanatic too. I bet I could talk her into trying some of these... she makes great spaghetti and lasagna, this would fit right in the line up. You take things I never thought of, and make me realize how much I need them!

Audrey Kirchner (author) from Washington on August 08, 2010:

As they say, old dogs, new tricks and all that - but I always like the challenge of doing something 'new and different' - especially if there is a gadget involved! Happy pasta-ing!

Holle Abee from Georgia on August 08, 2010:

I have never made these types of homemade pasta. Can you believe that?? Guess I'll have to learn!

Audrey Kirchner (author) from Washington on August 07, 2010:

Thanks so much for stopping by, equealla - and you are SO right! The day I made ravioli from scratch (no machines, no nothing) and another day that I made cannelloni - yum - it was SO good I didn't want to eat it! But of course we did! The machines make it a little less time consuming but the finished product is as you say - WONDERFUL!

equealla from Pretoria, South Africa on August 07, 2010:

Once you have tasted home made pasta-a-la-mama-italia, the stuff in the shops tastes like plastic.

I make mine with a little manual machine, and this seems so easy with this fancy machine. I love the videos as well, showing how to... Great hub.

Audrey Kirchner (author) from Washington on August 07, 2010:

Thanks BKCreative for stopping by - I just love mine and have so many gadgets for it it is a bit ridiculous already but they really DO work!

BkCreative from Brooklyn, New York City on August 07, 2010:

I've been wanting to try these gadgets. And homemade just has to taste so much better. Thanks so much for the information. I'll look into it now!

Audrey Kirchner (author) from Washington on August 06, 2010:

Thanks, Katie for stopping by - I love mine because I can use it for so many other things!

Katie McMurray from Westerville on August 06, 2010:

Ewwww I have a kitchen aid and use it for SO many things. I love the pasta gadget and attachment I can easily utilize with my very dependable Kitchen Aid Mixer!

Audrey Kirchner (author) from Washington on August 06, 2010:

HH - I guess that is true - techno world and all that! It does beat making the noodles from scratch which I've done, too but yikes - it's a whole day affair.

CM - The fact that you have one is impressive! I held off for many years thinking I did not 'need one' but it sure is a handy thing!

carolina muscle from Charlotte, North Carolina on August 06, 2010:

I want one of those... I'm waiting for my old Sunbeam to wear out.

Hello, hello, from London, UK on August 06, 2010:

The humble spagetti definitely was made into a scientific project. Gosh what all you need to make them.

Audrey Kirchner (author) from Washington on August 05, 2010:

Thanks Pamela for stopping in - I agree. Everything they make is golden! The pasta is delicious but I have made pasta without it too - more hubs to come I guess!

Pamela Oglesby from Sunny Florida on August 05, 2010:

Audry, Great hub. Kitchen Aid is such a good product. I have never made pasta but I bet it is so much better than what you buy at the store.

Audrey Kirchner (author) from Washington on August 05, 2010:

BJ - Ah yes, Bow-Tie Bombshell just fits the bill....too hilarious on the guys cooking and I believe in equal titles....just because I'm female, can't I be Lord of something...or is that Lordess? And the day I see Bob using my KitchenAid or any other 'equipment' in the kitchen, I may have a heart attack! Although he is a devil with a peeler and he's been known to whip things for me....with a spoon...although come to think of it....ha ha! I always tell him I'd love to see him in an apron though. You gotta keep it spiced up after all!

Audrey Kirchner (author) from Washington on August 05, 2010:

Thanks for stopping in, AH - I know what you mean. Until a year ago, I had no idea either. I just love making pasta when it is cold and dreary out so looking forward to fall and winter for that! Now I have to decide if I want to invest in yet one more gadget...but they truly are wonderful things. Thanks so much for reading!

drbj and sherry from south Florida on August 05, 2010:

Lord of Lasagna??? Is there something you're not telling me, a?

OK, You can be Lady Lasagna, Countess Capelini and Bow-Tie Bombshell.

I would love to have a KitchenAide, too, but the guys I know are all lousy cooks.

Nancy Hinchliff from Essex Junction, Vermont on August 05, 2010:

Wow!. I have a Kitchen Aid mixer, which I love. I had no idea you could get all those attachments to make those different kinds of pasta. Thanks, Audrey. Great hub. Love the videos.

Audrey Kirchner (author) from Washington on August 05, 2010:

If you cook a lot, Sandy - it will pay for itself I swear! I use mine all the time and just love it. Hoping you get your wish!!

Sandy Mertens from Wisconsin, USA on August 04, 2010:

This is on my wish list. I have always wanted a KitchenAid.

Audrey Kirchner (author) from Washington on August 04, 2010:

One more thing - Can I be Lord of Lasagna? Or Contessa of Capellini? I probably could be the Bitch of Bow-Tie as well but I will try NOT to get that title! And if I get a crown, I only want DRIED pasta - not cooked. That would not be a good thing. (I can't believe you went prostrate for me either! I am so touched!)

Audrey Kirchner (author) from Washington on August 04, 2010:

BJ, I want what you're having for an afternoon beverage! You are too hilarious. If I get my comedy gig writing, you are going to have to be my partner. You never cease to crack me up. Love it and I shall be honored to wear my pasta crown!

I can't believe I get suckered in by gadgets though. I do not have enough cupboards to house all my culinary tools is the problem. I use them all so this is good but you know - there is only so much counter space! I need a bigger kitchen - that's it!!

Thanks for reading and for making me laugh at the end of a long, long day!

drbj and sherry from south Florida on August 04, 2010:

I hereby dub you, Audrea, the Princess of Prolific Pasta.

Also Sovereign of Spaghetti, Royal Ruler of Rigatoni,

Contessa of Formidable Fusilli, Empress of Beatific Bucatini, and Madame of Magnificent Macaroni, large and small.

I prostrate myself (that's prostrate with an "r") before your amazing lexicon of pasta lore. And I bet you can whip up a pungent, piquant pizza.

"Cogratulations sulla vostra conoscenza pasta!"