Skip to main content

How to Barbecue Oysters

Paul is a barbecue enthusiast. He is currently grilling and smoking on a Komodo Kamado Ultimate 23.

Oysters, a Grilled Treat!

I'm a huge fan of fresh oysters. Typically, I shuck them and eat them raw with a little Tapatio sauce and maybe some fresh lemon juice. However, this weekend I was introduced to barbecued oysters. Oysters are beautifully simplistic to grill and taste profoundly different than slurping them raw from the shell. Plus, since oysters are grilled in the shell, the only preparation is starting the grill!

Virginia Bluepoint Oyster in shell on the bbq

Virginia Bluepoint Oyster in shell on the bbq

Selecting Oysters to Grill

There are a handful of oysters available commercially that are ideal for barbecuing. For barbecuing, I recommend the large or jumbo sized Pacific Oyster that are grown in the Willapa Bay of Washington. Willapa bay is some of the cleanest water used for growing oysters. For people on the East Coast, Bluepoint oysters from Rhode Island are robust and large enough to barbecue, although I suggest avoiding the Virginia Bluepoints since they tend to be more bland in my experience.

A little know fact about oysters is that they come in different sizes. The raw ones at the fresh seafood market are likely smalls. Baked oysters are usually mediums and for barbecuing, I recommend larges or jumbos. The small ones don't do well on the grill. Mainly because they shrivel up and dry out. As opposed to the large ones that tend to have more fluid and juices that keep them moist while they cook. However, since most people eat oysters raw, and those are traditionally small oysters, it's a bit more difficult to find the larger ones for barbecuing.

The ideal size for grilling oysters is about three to four inches long and about one to two inches deep. Pacific Oysters have a curved bottom side to their shell with a relatively flat top. The spoon shape actually does very well when placed on a grill.

Tips for BBQ Oysters

  • Only fresh oysters should be grilled
  • Purchase large or jumbo oysters for grilling
  • Have oysters packed in ice at the time of purchase
  • People's appetite for oysters vary. As an appetizer, plan on three to four oysters per person. A real oyster lover can eat over a dozen:)

Order Oysters to BBQ Online

It can be really hard to find the right size and type of oyster to barbecue, so I did a little research and found the following places that will ship them to you in the same day.

Large Willapa Bay Oysters (Pacific Oysters)

Grilling the Oysters

Grilling oysters is just about the simplest meat I've ever grilled.

  • Heat the grill to a hot temperature of around 400 degrees.
  • Oysters are grilled over direct heat.
  • Place the oysters directly over the flames with the flat side of the shell up.
  • Close or cover the barbecue.
  • Let the oysters cook for 10 minutes for large and jumbo sizes. For medium oysters grill them for 7 minutes.
Not all oysters open when barbecued

Not all oysters open when barbecued

Shucking the BBQ Oysters

If you're not experienced at shucking oysters, the sharp shells can be a bit dangerous. I actually sliced my thumb pretty bad opening one of the oysters. However, a really cool thing about oysters on the grill is they open up like when you steam clams or muscles. After the oysters have been on the grill, they open up about 1/4 of an inch and a pairing knife can be used to peel the top shell.

Oyster in half shell

Oyster in half shell

Shucking Hot Oysters

To shuck a hot oyster use:

  • Shucking knife
  • Neoprene oven mitt

Oysters come off the grill extremely hot.

Scroll to Continue

1. Place all the oysters in a large bowl.

2. Put the hot mitt on your hand

3. Holding the oyster firmly in the hand with the mitt, place the shucking knife between the fluted part of the shell where the top and bottom come together and push and twist at the same time. (This takes practice)

4. As the knife slides in, bring it around the top of the shell to sever the oyster from the shell.

5. Serve out of the bottom shell


Serving the Oysters

Here are three ways to serve barbecued oysters

  • Fresh cocktail sauce (I mix my own with a 1/4 cup catchup, fresh squeezed lemon and horseradish to taste)
  • Melted butter with garlic or lemon
  • Tapatio sauce with lemon

Using a small fork, remove the oyster from the shell and dip into your favorite sauce. Enjoy!

Barbecued Oyster in Cocktail Sauce

Barbecued Oyster in Cocktail Sauce


Maurice Glaude from Mobile on August 31, 2015:

Oh Yes my family loves them raw, buttered and hot sauce, steamed and grilled... Its usually a messy feast and we love it.

Kim Lam from California on July 23, 2013:

I must be a real oyster lover because I can actually eat a dozen! But for some reason I've always been intimidated by grilling them. So I usually let my husband do the grilling and shucking. Great tutorial.

CraftytotheCore on July 18, 2013:

I live in Connecticut on the shoreline. I grew up on raw oysters, steamers, mussels, etc. I like oysters on the half shell with tabasco and lemon. I've never had them barbecued before, but they look delicious! I've noticed recently what's big around here are fried and roasted oysters.

Devika Primić from Dubrovnik, Croatia on June 11, 2013:

Looks so delicious and a great selection of oysters

Susan Hazelton from Northern New York on June 04, 2013:

I love oyster but never heard of bbq. It looks like I will be trying them - with melted butter and garlic, of course.

Jacob Long from Memphis, TN on June 03, 2013:

I'm with Cardisa, never crossed my mind to barbecue them. Great hub!

Carolee Samuda from Jamaica on June 03, 2013:

I love oysters but never thought of BBQ-ing them. I usually have then raw with the sauce the guys make....don't ask me the name or

Related Articles