Updated date:

Gluten Free Pie Crust Review

Gluten Free Pantry Perfect Pie Crust Mix

Gluten Free Pantry Perfect Pie Crust Mix

As more and more people are looking to eliminate gluten from their diet, there is an abundance of gluten free foods available. The question is--which ones are any good? In my search to find the easiest gluten free pie crust with the best taste, I am reviewing two products available. Until recently, my only experience with gluten free pie crusts is the frozen product, which has a less desirable flavor and can put a damper on any homemade pie.

The first product is a Gillian's Foods Gluten Free Frozen Pie Crust found at Whole Foods and other health concious grocers. The second is a Gluten Free Pantry Perfect Pie Crust Mix which comes in a box. It is made by the Glutino company who has been making gluten free foods since 1983. The first thing to keep in mind is contrary to the product title, it is NOT perfect! When you are used to eating a homemade flaky pie crust, or even a Pillsbury refrigerated crust, gluten free just isn't the same texture or taste. Once you have accepted that fact, your expectation of the finished product will be more realistic.



What is Gluten?

Gluten is an ingredient found in foods processed from wheat and related grain species, including barley and rye. It can also be found in some oats if they are contaminated with other wheat products. When you remove gluten from most foods, it is quite noticeable. Gluten especially plays an important role in breads and baked goods. Gluten provides elasticity in dough and helps it to rise and to keep its shape. It often gives the final product a chewy texture. Gluten substitutes are improving allowing gluten free foods to have a much better flavor and texture than earlier versions.

Ingredients for the Gluten Free Pantry Perfect Pie Crust Mix

  • entire bag Perfect Pie Crust Mix
  • 1/4 tsp baking powder
  • 2 tbsp sugar, optional
  • 10 tbsp unsalted butter, cold, cut in small pieces
  • 10 tbsp butter flavored vegetable shortening, in small pieces
  • 2 eggs, beaten
  • 2 tbsp cold water
  • 3 tsp cider vinegar
Be mindful to use cold water and cold butter

Be mindful to use cold water and cold butter

Use gluten free flour on your rolling board

Use gluten free flour on your rolling board

Gluten free pie crust is not perfect!

Gluten free pie crust is not perfect!

Directions

The directions on the box are easy to follow but you do have to pay attention and be prepared to use cold, unsalted butter. If you use room temperature butter, it will not mix as well. Even with that I found the dough to be sticky and gloppy, like it needed more flour. I resisted adding more flour and only used the ingredient list on the box. I followed the directions and wrapped it into two balls and refrigerated the dough.

After an hour I tried to roll out the dough onto a surface covered with gluten free flour. Unlike regular bread dough or pie crust, this was hard to roll out with a rolling pin. I found the dough to be quite crumbly and difficult to roll out to a desired thickness. When transferring it to the pie plate, the dough wanted to fall apart. The crust was thicker than what I anticipated so I used wax paper and my fingers to attempt to make it thinner in the pie plate. I attempted to crimp the edges of the pie crust to at least make it look pretty, but found that challenging.

I converted my homemade peach pie recipe into a gluten free version by substituting Bolts Red Mill Gluten Free All Purpose Baking Flour in place of regular flour. My family did not notice any difference in the peach pie filling, but the crust--well, that is a different story. Suprisingly, the crust ended up being more flaky than I anticipated but it had a different texture; it was more grainy tasting.


Gluten free peach pie

Gluten free peach pie

Gluten Free Pie Crust Analysis

The Gillian's Foods Gluten Free Frozen Pie Crust is straightforward--just add your filling and bake. Its crust stays together well, but it does not turn out flaky and it is void of any real taste. When comparing the Gluten Free Pantry Perfect Pie Crust Mix to Gillian's frozen crust, I have to say that the mix did have a superior taste, but not enough to justify the time spent mixing and rolling out dough. My next gluten free pie will likely use the frozen pie crust just to save time. However, my family ate the entire pie--no crumbs left! Even better is that fact that my daughter was so appreciative of my efforts to make a gluten free pie. There is lots of love that goes into homemade cooking!

Do you have a favorite gluten free product? Please share!

LauraGSpeaks (author) from Raleigh, NC on November 23, 2018:

Hi Matt, Thanks for your comments. I hope your Thanksgiving pies were a big hit!

Matt on November 19, 2018:

I am most grateful to have found your review--this is my favorite GF crust, and horror of horrors, Glutino messed up the recipe when they redesigned the box! Fortunately the product inside seems to be the same as it used to be--if you follow the directions you have printed here, it turns out just fine! (If you use the directions on the box, however, the texture is off and the crust is pretty tasteless)

Your pointers and tips in working with the dough are also much appreciated.

I'll be making two GF/DF pumpkin pies this week for the whole Thanksgiving crowd--and, thanks to you, I don't predict any crust left behind on plates!

Mara on January 13, 2015:

Its like you read my mind! You appear to know a whole lot about this, like you wrote the book in it or sonhteimg. I believe which you could do with several pics to drive the message home a bit, but other than that, this really is wonderful weblog. A fantastic read. I

Karen Lackey from Ohio on September 14, 2012:

Great review, Laura! I have a highschool friend who opened a gluten free bakery for this very reason. She could not good tasting, gluten free options! Up and useful!

LauraGSpeaks (author) from Raleigh, NC on September 13, 2012:

denisemai, I think we will continue to see more and more gluten free options as the demand for these products increases. With such busy lives, pre made options would be a huge benefit. Thanks for reading!

Denise Mai from Idaho on September 12, 2012:

Wow. It's nice that you tried these products out and weighed in. It will save others time. I know duplicating gluten based recipes with gluten free ingredients can be hard. It would be great if there were some tasty premade options.