Updated date:

Types of Puzzles- Choosing Puzzles for Young Children

Author:

Rose Mary, an Occupational Therapist since 1987, is experienced with pre-term infants, early intervention, school therapy, and home health.

Elmo connecting puzzles

Elmo connecting puzzles

When it comes to timeless, classic toys for kids, puzzles are hard to beat. Through puzzles, young children can explore visual perceptual concepts, and refine hand manipulation skills. And of course none of this would work if puzzles weren’t just plain fun. How many times does the average child put together a single puzzle, before that child is ready to get rid of that puzzle? Hundreds? Thousands? How many toys have this kind of appeal to young children?

Jigsaw puzzles originated in 1760 in England, made by a mapmaker to help children learn geography. From there, puzzles were used to help children learn history, with kings and queens depicted in puzzles. These puzzles were expensive, handcrafted from wood. Puzzles became more affordable and were popularized in the 1920s and 1930s.

Types of Puzzles

There are three main categories of puzzles, non-connecting puzzles, connecting puzzles, and interlocking puzzles. Some consider this to be the progression of difficulty with puzzles, but that is not necessarily true. Let’s explore each type of puzzle, and how to modify puzzles when they are too difficult. This should help you choose the appropriate puzzles for your child.

Non-Connecting Puzzles

The simplest of puzzles for young children are non-connecting puzzles. These are puzzles made up of separate pieces that do not fit with each other. For example, a 4-piece puzzle with an apple, banana, bunch of grapes, and watermelon slice. Another example would be a 4-piece puzzle with shapes, such as a circle, square, triangle, and rectangle. My favorite is a 5-shape puzzle that is a house. The door is a rectangle, the window a square, the sun is a circle.

This house shape puzzle with large knobs is a favorite. It is often the first puzzle that some of my clients are able to successfully complete.

This house shape puzzle with large knobs is a favorite. It is often the first puzzle that some of my clients are able to successfully complete.

From simple 4-piece puzzles, progress to non-connecting puzzles with up to 12 pieces. Examples might be puzzles with zoo animals, farm animals, fish, dinosaurs, cars, or trucks. If the puzzle is too difficult for the child, place half the pieces in the board for the child. Talk about the shape, color, or other attributes of the remaining pieces to be placed.

Non-connecting puzzles can however be difficult for young children. If you present a puzzle with six to ten shapes to a child that barely knows four shapes, that could be too hard for the child. Likewise, an alphabet puzzle with 26 pieces would likely be too difficult for a child who doesn’t know any alphabet letters. I often use alphabet puzzles with young clients as an alphabet recognition activity to learn letters. Separate the letters by row, and present the letter pieces for one row at a time. A favorite among my therapy kids is the Melissa and Doug alphabet puzzle starting with an alligator for "A". See my photo.

Alphabet Non-Connecting Puzzles with and without Knobs

Melissa & Doug non-connecting alphabet puzzles. Puzzle pieces on left do not have knobs.  Pieces from puzzle on the right have knobs.

Melissa & Doug non-connecting alphabet puzzles. Puzzle pieces on left do not have knobs. Pieces from puzzle on the right have knobs.

Alphabet Non-Connecting Puzzle

Large Melissa & Doug non-connecting alphabet puzzle.  Separate letters by row for younger children.

Large Melissa & Doug non-connecting alphabet puzzle. Separate letters by row for younger children.

Foam Inset Non-Connecting Number Puzzle

Dollar Store non-connecting number puzzle

Dollar Store non-connecting number puzzle

Connecting Puzzles

The transition from non-connecting puzzles to connecting puzzles can be quite a jump for young children. The perceptual skills required are much more complex. These puzzles are usually board puzzles, and therefore do not have a picture for the child to reference, like a boxed puzzle would. Neither do they have the picture on the board as a reference for where the pieces might go. Therefore first connecting puzzles can be very challenging for young children.

The pieces of connecting puzzles are placed with edges in full contact with other pieces to form the picture, but pieces don’t interlock. Companies like Hasbro, Milton Bradley, and Playskool make 9-piece connecting puzzles, with popular characters like Elmo, Pooh, Dora, and Diego. Make these puzzles easier by tracing the outline of the pieces on the board. Put the puzzle together with the child, and place some of the pieces. Let the child put pieces together that form the character’s face, and assist with edge pieces, and background images.

Another way to make connecting puzzles easier is to take full-frame photos of the assembled puzzle. Print the puzzle, then trim the edges until it fits in the puzzle board. The child can then put the puzzle together matching the picture.

Make a Photo Model of Puzzle

I took pictures of the assembled puzzles with my phone, printed, then trimmed to size for the puzzle board.

I took pictures of the assembled puzzles with my phone, printed, then trimmed to size for the puzzle board.

I bought several small connecting puzzles from the $1 bin at Target. These puzzles had 5- to 7-pieces, and depicted a barn, a cow, an airplane, and an ambulance. These puzzles are challenging! Again I would suggest outlining the pieces on the puzzle board, or placing some of the pieces for the child. For example, place the barn and let the child fill in the windows, or place the body of the airplane and let the child place the wings.

Small Connecting Puzzles

Small 5- to 7- piece non connecting puzzles from Target, $1 each.

Small 5- to 7- piece non connecting puzzles from Target, $1 each.

Some connecting puzzles come with many pieces. Connecting puzzles from wood or foam have been staples of Occupational Therapy clinics. These puzzles, especially those with 15 or more pieces, are extremely difficult. Without a picture reference, they are often challenging for adults, and nearly impossible for kids. Trace the pieces on the board, or make a notebook with photos of the finished puzzles.

Lauri Foam Connecting Puzzles

I've had several therapy clients, children with autism, who really loved these puzzles

I've had several therapy clients, children with autism, who really loved these puzzles

Interlocking Puzzles

Interlocking puzzles, or jigsaw puzzles, are what most adults think of when referring to “puzzles”. These puzzles have a classic tongue and groove that interlock to hold pieces together. An interlocking puzzle is also connecting, but connecting puzzles are not interlocking.

4- and 5-Piece Interlocking Puzzles

4- and 5-piece interlocking puzzles may not be as simple as you think.

4- and 5-piece interlocking puzzles may not be as simple as you think.

Although you may find 4-piece interlocking puzzles, and a few 5- and 9-piece puzzles, 12-piece puzzles and above are more common. In the past I was able to get 12-piece interlocking puzzles with the full-sized matching picture on the board from discount stores like Big Lot’s, Family Dollar, and Dollar General for about $3. More recently I have had to buy them from Amazon or Walmart for around $10.

9-Piece Interlocking Puzzles

These are $1 puzzles from Mighty Dollar

These are $1 puzzles from Mighty Dollar

12-Piece Boxed Puzzles with Pictures

Ravensburger has a line of 12-piece puzzles with 2 puzzles in each box. Included are full-sized picture for each puzzle.

Ravensburger has a line of 12-piece puzzles with 2 puzzles in each box. Included are full-sized picture for each puzzle.

Adapting Puzzles with More Pieces

There are many ways to adapt interlocking puzzles. If time is limited, you can choose a portion of a 60- or 100-piece puzzle, but don’t have to complete the puzzle. Have the child choose the pieces for the main character’s face, or face and body. Reference the picture on the box, and talk about features to look for from the picture.

Visit my article, Using Puzzles with a Group of Children for more ideas for working with young children on interlocking puzzles.

Boxed Puzzle with 3 Scenes from Lion King

Look for pieces of specific character, to put together a portion of a puzzle.

Look for pieces of specific character, to put together a portion of a puzzle.

© 2012 rmcrayne

Comments

Lisa Bean from Nevada on December 19, 2018:

You've certainly shown a great variety of puzzles! Our kids have always loved them and I've found them to be a great activity for the whole family. My 8 year old is currently working on a 600 piece puzzle and despite it's amount of pieces, he's determined to finish it! We've got maybe 1/4 of it complete, but seeing his determination is pretty cool. Yay for puzzles! :)