Skip to main content

Who Would Win In A Fight? Cast Your Vote!

who-would-win-in-a-fight

One Of The Best Games You'll Ever Play

If you've never played the who would win in a fight game, you don't know what you've been missing. There is no other better way to pass time than arguing who would beat who in an all-out one on one slug fest. Although comic book fans have always thought about such things, a lot more people began to come up with fight scenarios when the film Fight Club came out. I, for one, am very glad of that as it allows everyone to partake in this very entertaining game.

Lady Gaga versus Kesha. Superman versus Spiderman. Plants versus zombies. Who would win? Once you realize that you can pit anyone or anything against anyone or anything else, you'll start to realize the appeal of the game. The possibilities are truly endless. Below are just a few of the fights that I would like to see and have in fact argued amongst friends of mine. If you find one that catches your attention, be sure to cast your vote and comment as to why they would win... or lose.

Photo by Kelly Bailey / flickr.

robot-chicken-vs-locutus-of-borg

robot-chicken-vs-locutus-of-borg

Things To Keep In Mind When Trying To Decide Who Would Win In A Fight

One on one. Mano a mano. Two men enter, one man leaves.

Weapons / Equipment: This can be a major deciding factor in a fight to the death, especially if each item is from a totally different time period (bronze vs. steel).

Physical Conditioning: This would take into account strength, speed, endurance and agility. How long one can fight at peak performance is perhaps one of the more important criteria when trying to decide who would win in a fight.

Fighting Skill / Smarts: Being able to fight well and think on the fly can be the difference between winning and losing, no matter if the bout lasts 10 minutes or 10 hours.

Morals: You've got to admit that someone who doesn't care if they hurt others and are willing to kill have a slight advantage over those who do care about such things. Some would say that it's a huge advantage.

Powers / Special Advantages: This is a big deciding factor and for good reason. It's also the reason why when most people are choosing opponents, they try to keep it on a reasonably equal playing field. Let's be realistic, would you want to see a fight between Superman and a tiger? Of course not, that wouldn't even be a fight now would it?

pirates-versus-ninjas

pirates-versus-ninjas

The pirate has a definite advantage with firearms, but I believe the ninja would strike before the pirate knew what hit them. If the ninja could survive any initial blast directed his way, odds go into his favor.

Who would win in a fight? A tough one for sure.

batman-versus-bruce-lee

batman-versus-bruce-lee

This would be an epic battle, especially if Lee were allowed a few weapons - which would only be fair. In the end though, I think Batman would have the edge over Lee because of all the extras he has (armor, gadgets, etc).

Stick Fight (Red versus Blue) - Cool Animation by Michael Lubin

How do you choose who would win in a fight like this? Some battles are just too close to call.

eric-cartman-vs-bart-simpson

eric-cartman-vs-bart-simpson

Two of the baddest boys of animation go at it until the bitter end. My money is on the devious one. I can't help to think back to the South Park episode where Cartman took revenge on a boy by turning his parents into chili. If Bart has a chance of winning, he would have to dominate Cartman and not let up on him.

The undead versus the rotting dead.

vampires-vs-zombies

vampires-vs-zombies

Scroll to Continue

Think of this battle as one vampire against a lot of zombies, say 100? In a straight one on one battle the zombies wouldn't stand a chance against a vampire.

Talk about an amazing catfight.

baroness-vs-tomb-raider

baroness-vs-tomb-raider

When trying to decide who would win in a fight between these two women, it would probably come down to who is more physical. If Lara Croft could avoid being sniped off, she would probably be able to take out The Baroness.

A brutul, but short monster fight.

king-kong-vs-godzilla

king-kong-vs-godzilla

Although the fight between these two over-sized monsters would be something to behold, it would also be short. Godzilla would take King Kong out due to all the extra power he has (fire, electricity, etc.).

conan-vs-kratos

conan-vs-kratos

For this to be a fair fight, there should be no magic involved, but life isn't always fair is it? Conan would give Kratos all he could ask for, but in the end - Conan would lose.

hulk-vs-iron-man

hulk-vs-iron-man

Who would win this fight would come down to just how much of a beating Iron Man's suit could really take. If he can take the beating that the Hulk would meet out, I think that the Hulk would eventually grow tired or perhaps even turn back into human form.

teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-vs-predator

teenage-mutant-ninja-turtles-vs-predator

This fight is too close to call, but I would love to see four turtle shells hanging on a wall next to the Predator's other trophies. That's just me, of course.

Star Trek Versus Star Wars - William Shatner weighs in on the debate.

Fight Club - The franchise that made me want to write this lens.

This film helped bring a game that many comic book fans have been playing for a very long time into the public spotlight and I for one am glad it did. Trust me, there is no better way to pass the time on a long trip than debating who would win in a fight - Robin vs. Lobo, Lincoln vs. Washington, zombie vs. werewolf and on and on. Give it a try some time and you'll see what I mean.

Fight Club Framed Poster (38 x17 in.)

The First Rule - the Art of Justin Reed

Buy for $124.99

stormshadow-vs-grendel

stormshadow-vs-grendel

I would love to see that nice white uniform get some red on it, and I think Hunter Rose is just the man to do it. I'm pulling for Grendel to win this brutal fight.

jason-voorhees-vs-leatherface

jason-voorhees-vs-leatherface

Who couldn't defend themselves against a glove; I wanna see Jason defend himself against a chainsaw. I don't believe Leatherface is the type of person to stop sawing prematurely. He seems to like it. I like Leatherface in this fight.

terminator-vs-wolverine

terminator-vs-wolverine

Trying to figure out who would win this fight could give you a headache. Sparks are gonna fly when these two go up against each other - literally. Possible a draw?

vampirella-vs-buffy-the-vampire-slayer

vampirella-vs-buffy-the-vampire-slayer

Buffy has handled all vampires that have come her way, so far, but I still would like to see them go at it. This could be one of the most sexiest girl fights that ever goes down. The odds are in Buffy's favor, though.

darth-vader-vs-magneto

darth-vader-vs-magneto

Both are able to move things with their minds. Something tells me there may be a lot of collateral damage in this match-up. Magneto may have a slight edge, especially if Vader's armor and lightsaber is made out of a type of metal that Magneto can have control over. If not, the edge goes to Vader.

highlander-vs-the-crow

highlander-vs-the-crow

Two of my all time favorite characters. I wouldn't know who to cheer for. Both have healing properties, know how to fight and know how to use weapons. On one hand The Crow is more experienced with firearms, but killing the bird can take away his powers. Whoever found out the weakness of the other first would have a definite advantage. I don't know who would win this fight, but it would be an awesome fight to behold.

Imagine the two greatest boxers of all time going against one another in their prime.

muhammad-ali-vs-rocky-marciano

muhammad-ali-vs-rocky-marciano

Ali definitely has more skill and talent, but can be quite arrogant at times. I think Marciano would catch him off guard a few times, but Ali would win in the end. The win, however, would probably be by decision and not by KO.

Who Would Win In A Fight - Suggestions - Let everyone know who you would like to see do battle with each other.

BattlestarTrekWars on April 27, 2014:

Setinnel vs Transformer

Tick vs Neo (Spoon vs no spoon)

Han Solo vs G.I. Joe

anonymous on June 02, 2012:

Zeus vs ra

Terry Lomax from Rep. of Ireland on May 26, 2012:

the Hulk v Somalian pirates, all out war between wild birds and the worlds mosquito population, Wasps v anyone who abuses women or kids.

anonymous on March 25, 2012:

@anonymous: The shark would win in the short term, but it would probably die due to feeding on zombie flesh. Both would lose.

anonymous on March 20, 2012:

I can't believe you didn't include Shark Vs. Zombie. (Shark would win.)

anonymous on March 17, 2012:

I've got a few suggestion on who I'd like to see in a fight. Hope you like 'em.

Harry Potter versus Ant Man

Sylvester Stallone versus Lady GaGa

Kelly Clarkson versus Kesha

Pen versus Sword

Knight versus Grizzly Bear

anonymous on March 09, 2012:

Awesome article!!! I would love to see a fight to the death against two old people, that would be so cool. Perfect for a scene in a movie, don't you think?

sukkran trichy from Trichy/Tamil Nadu on February 21, 2012:

very interesting polls. well crafted lens.

lftypjk900 on February 21, 2012:

Cool Concept! Like your lens! Can't thing of anyone I would like to see to fight each other!!!!

Related Articles