The Songs the BBC Decided to Ban
Over the years, the BBC (British Broadcasting Corporation) has been the UK's standard bearer of taste and decency, which included those songs it felt should not be transmitted to the nation's ears.
Although the BBC has never admitted to banning a song or a piece of music, its crazy censorship has sometimes seen a record unceremoniously dumped from its various playlists. The practice has been going on since the 1930s, when songs by the likes of Noel Coward, Cole Porter, George Formby and later, Johnnie Ray, Frankie Laine and Bobby Darin came under the scrutiny of what has become known as "Auntie Beeb".
This "auntie knows best" image stretched into the 1960s and beyond, when the Corporation was faced with such cultural upheavals as the burgeoning drug culture, the sexual revolution and the growth of a more politically aware youth.
But, by today's standards, it seems laughable that most of the tracks featured here were refused airplay and chosen as songs banned by the BBC.
The Beatles: A Day in the Life
Along with Eleanor Rigby, this is one of my favourite tracks by The Beatles. Taken from one of their most innovative and influential albums, Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band, A Day in the Life came under the scrutiny of the BBC censors when the disc was released back in 1967.
What was the problem? Along with several other Beatles songs, there appeared to be something of an underlying reference to drug use, which Auntie Beeb did not want to be seen as advocating. In particular, it referenced lyrics such as "I'd love to turn you on" and "found my way upstairs and had a smoke, and somebody spoke and I went into a dream", which the Corporation interpreted as promoting drugs.
John Lennon and Paul McCartney refuted the accusation at the time, but Beatles producer George Martin has since commented that the BBC's suspicions were probably grounded in truth.
Donna Summer: Love to Love You Baby
Back in the day, when disco music was going through puberty, along came Donna Summer to help kick it into adulthood.
It was 1975 when Ms. Summer recorded the now notorious Love to Love You Baby. Full of steamy and erotic moans and groans, the disc appeared as a gigantic blip on the BBC's "no-no" radar as soon as it started to become popular. Although it was never officially banned, the Corporation limited its airplay enough to make the public curious to know what the fuss was all about. Whether this contributed to it becoming a Top 10 hit is debatable, but it went on to register as one of the most successful early disco hits of the era.
Personally, I still have the original album on which the full track appears. Lasting around fifteen minutes or so, the song probably contains more "oohs" and "aahs" than any other committed to vinyl, before or since.
Frankie Goes to Hollywood: Relax
Frankie Goes to Hollywood epitomised the high energy, funky dance music of the 1980s and their first release, Relax caused the stuffed shirts at the BBC to near seizures, and it was quickly assigned to the banned list.
The ban was initially prompted by then DJ, Mike Read, who publicly refused to play the song on his radio show, having interpreted and then citing the lyrics as "sexually explicit". Almost simultaneously, the BBC slapped its "no play" edict on the track, and it went unheard both on BBC radio and television throughout most of 1984.
Commercial radio stations had continued to play the track throughout the controversy, and by Christmas 1984 the BBC had been embarrassed into relaxing their Relax policy.
The song would go on to reach the Number One position on the UK charts, and become the country's seventh best selling single of all time. It also won Best British Single at the Brit Awards of 1985.
Napoleon XIV: They're Coming to Take Me Away Ha-Haaa!
Transatlantic controversy courted this novelty song almost immediately upon its release in 1966.
They're Coming to Take Me Away Ha-Haaa! recorded by Napoleon XIV (aka Jerry Samuels) came under fire in both the UK and the US for its apparent parody of mental illness. Things got so bad in America, protesters managed to get the track banned from some radio stations altogether. The same fate was awaiting the song in the UK too.
This didn't stop it becoming a Top 5 hit on both sides of the Atlantic.
The Troggs: I Can't Control Myself
The Troggs were one of the major British Invasion groups of the 1960s, and are probably best remembered for their mega hit Wild Thing. They have also often been cited as the inspiration for later punk rock and garage rock bands.
However, back in 1966, the group ran into trouble with the BBC, not for Wild Thing, but for this track: I Can't Control Myself. Although it was not officially banned, the Corporation made sure that it was denied much radio airplay because of their ruling of "lewdly suggestive sounds by (lead singer) Reg Presley."
Now, I've listened to this song several times, and if the lyrics are "lewd sounds", then yes, they are mildly suggestive. However, I hear nothing else happening here.
Gainsbourg & Birkin: Je t'aime...moi non plus
Quite possibly one of the most famously banned songs of all time is this gem from 1969, by Serge Gainsbourg and Jane Birkin.
Je t'aime...moi non plus really had the executives at the BBC all steamed up, but not in a way you might think. The song sent them scuttling for their French dictionaries, and fainting ensued when Jane Birkin started to moan and groan erotically towards the end of the track.
The UK was not the only country to ban the song, as several nations across Europe censored it from their radio stations. It caused such a furor, that even the Vatican became involved, stating that it was "offensive". This all helped the disc to reach Number One in the UK; the first time a Number One had been slapped with a ban. By today's standards, all the controversy seems mildly amusing.
Wings: Hi, Hi, Hi
While, on several occasions, The Beatles found themselves in trouble with the censor, Paul McCartney's new group, Wings, had the misfortune of having two singles banned in the same year: 1972.
In February, the BBC took exception to the band's Top Twenty hit, Give Ireland Back to the Irish, and promptly blacklisted the politically driven track. Then, in December, Hi, Hi, Hi was banned because of the lyrics "We're gonna get hi, hi, hi" (supposed drug references), as well as "get you ready for my body gun" (sexually suggestive).
McCartney explained that the actual lyric is "get you ready for my polygon". But, who knows for sure? It didn't stop the song becoming a Top Ten hit in the US, and when flipped with C Moon, a Top Five placing in the UK.
Scott Walker: Jackie
Scott Walker was the lead singer of the 1960s/70s vocal group, The Walker Brothers, whose smooth baritone voice graced several big selling hits of the era.
Once the group had split up for the first time, Walker went on to a solo career, recording songs which included English interpretations of the works of Belgian, Jacques Brel. One of the tracks he released as a single was Jackie, a tale about a prospective singer and his clients, set to a Spanish rhythm.
The lyrics were translated by famed songwriter Mort Shuman, but in the case of this song, the BBC found them way too risqué for broadcast in 1967.
Pogues: Fairytale of New York
A Christmas classic censored, I hear you ask?
Well, yes, for a few days. This song had been around since 1987, and had been freely played up until 2007, when suddenly the bosses at BBC Radio One (the BBC's pop music radio station) decided they were going to edit out several words for fear of offending a certain section of the population.
While this was not a blanket ban across all BBC stations, it did provoke a backlash of protest from the general public. Sanity was quickly restored, and some days later, the full unedited track was being played once again.
Max Romeo: Wet Dream
Max Romeo's naughty ditty caused some major uproar at the BBC back in 1969.
Romeo, an influential roots reggae singer, who had achieved significant success in his native Jamaica, wrote the lyrics to a previously recorded backing track, added his vocals, and then unceremoniously fell foul of the BBC censors.
As with most of the bans the BBC imposed, it only served to make the track even more popular. It went on to spend almost six months on the UK Singles Chart, peaking at Number 10. According to Max Romeo, his innuendo laden song is about a leaky roof dripping into a bedroom.
Banned Songs Discussed: Other Songs Censored By the BBC
- BBC censors The Pogues' Christmas classic
The BBC has censored a popular Christmas song amid fears the lyrics will upset homosexuals.
- The music the BBC banned
It's difficult to remember the last time the BBC banned a record.
- The artists censored by the BBC
Today it is common to hear such favourites as Frankie Laine's "Answer Me", Johnnie Ray's "Such a Night", the Coasters' "Charlie Brown", Bobby Darin's "Mack the Knife" and Barry McGuire's "Eve of Destruction" on BBC programmes, but all of them were or
- Revealed: The less than shocking classics the BBC banned
They are about as scandalous as a saucy seaside postcard but hundreds of classic songs - including George Fornby's With My Little Stick of Blackpool Rock - fell foul of BBC censors after being branded too risque for more innocent listeners.
- The songs censored by the BBC
The songs banned and modified by the BBC's Dance Music Policy Committee for causing offence.
About Your Author
With each article, Richard invites you to step into his world of music, television and entertainment. He will introduce you to British Glam Rock, share The 20 Scariest Film Scores Ever? and even give you an up close look at some classic actors such as Christopher Lee as Dracula.
For a complete list of Richard's articles, please visit Richard's profile.
© 2010 Richard
What Do You Think of These Banned Songs?
aaxiaa lm on November 04, 2013:
Great lens! I kind of suspected Gainsbourg here. :D
Sue-DN on December 20, 2012:
Scott Walker - my first love!! Still going strong, and respected by many of today's younger musicians. His music these days is very avant-garde - not to my taste any more, but I do admire him for it. He could make a heck of a lot of money if he released an album of classic songs, but he stays true to himself.
The Hatter from Great Britain on November 18, 2012:
Very interesting, self righteous BBC!
Mech from Bosnia and Herzegvina on November 17, 2012:
Hmm, I did not know most of this. Well, I wish we could ban half the music they are playing now. Though it's pointless to discuss tastes. :)
NibsyNell on September 28, 2012:
This I such a great lens. I can't believe some of the stuff that was censored/banned - they would have got a shock back then if they heard what we're listening to nowadays!
terrywoodhouse lm on July 07, 2012:
there always some body somewhere at the bbc who think they know best
IQplusone on June 21, 2012:
nice lens - thanks for sharing
natashaely on May 29, 2012:
I love your lenses, this is such an interesting one. It always amazzes me that they bother to ban anything, the moment it is banned interest in it will rise. Do you remember when Channel 4 banned Life of Brian, suddenly it became a great hit, you'd think they'd learn!
marzsquid on May 23, 2012:
I heard somewhere that Van Morrison's "Brown Eyed Girl" was banned in Boston. I know that's a catch phrase, but just wondering if the beeb banned that one, too?
AlexTedford on May 10, 2012:
This lens is certainly...unique. Thanks for sharing! I've loved all your lenses so far! :)
anonymous on April 29, 2012:
Oh wow. What a blast to the past - all those 60s banned songs - I remember them well :)
Paul from Montreal on April 25, 2012:
Wow, there are definitely some surprises in that list!
TheMummyNextDoor on April 20, 2012:
Well. We all know its happening don't we? Times have changed, although I can think of several songs now I wish they would ban!!
Ruthi on April 04, 2012:
Seems like the banning of a song helps it rise to the top! Silliness, just like with banned books.
Lemming13 on April 02, 2012:
Very entertaining lens - as a matter of fact the BBC once banned a Bing Crosby song! His version of 'Young and Healthy' from the musical 42nd Street was considered far too naughty...
TheLastResort LM on December 10, 2011:
These are all great songs - though I do understand why they got banned at the time they did. Thanks for sharing!
Lisa Auch from Scotland on October 03, 2011:
I did not know Donna Summers got banned! wow, great song too! the Pouges! Love it, it is the ultimate christmas Song! Whne you think of some of the lyrics in songs now, My daughter is 11 and can sometimes come and say mum, listen to THIS! I dont know where to look sometimes, then I need to tell her to not say that word EVER! Blessed becasue I always look back with fond memories whilst reading your pages!
ScottHolt on August 14, 2011:
I love most of these songs!
TopTenLists on July 22, 2011:
Great list of infamous songs!
goldenrulecomics from New Jersey on July 03, 2011:
It's funny how innocent some of these songs appear to our modern ears, which have become accustomed to hearing far more explicit lyrics every day.
Paul from Liverpool, England on June 21, 2011:
Don't blame the Beeb for all of these - they do have the Daily Mail and Rupert Murdoch's minions looking for ways to get at them. That said, they do overreact sometimes.
valsquidoo on April 17, 2011:
Banning them just makes them more interesting. Rock on!
Tony Payne from Southampton, UK on April 08, 2011:
I am trying to think of other songs that were banned by the BBC, I am sure there were lots more as well. Maybe it was just that they didn't play them and I had to tune in to Radio Luxembourg to listen to them.
jp1978 on April 06, 2011:
Interesting! A ban often creates the exact opposite intention of its intent.
reasonablerobby on April 02, 2011:
brilliant, I was 14 when Je T'aime came out and a friend brought a copy to my 14th birthday party...what renegades we were!
Mary from Chicago area on February 15, 2011:
returning to bless this lens as a new Soundtracks angel :)
Pete Schultz on February 11, 2011:
Very interesting, I recall a great Berkley Breathed cartoon on the topic of censorship, in which the character Opus notes: The editor of the Des Moines Register would just ****. The strip appeared after said editor refused to print some strips claiming they were too offensive.
Mary from Chicago area on January 06, 2011:
A Day in the Life & Fairytale of New York are both amazing songs in my book. Did not know they were banned! Cool lens topic!
Addy Bell on December 01, 2010:
In a tragic sort of way, it's encouraging to know that the (much more enlightened) beeb has censored the type of song that has sent Puritanical Americans over the bend. But, seriously ... "They're Coming To Take Me Away"? Really, BBC? REALLY?
javr from British Columbia, Canada on November 30, 2010:
Certainly a different time when they ban songs like those. Do they ban the modern rap songs as well?
julieannbrady on November 28, 2010:
In this day and age, I can't fathom songs being banned anywhere.
Blueyes01 on October 04, 2010:
Can;t believe the song " they're going to take me away ha-ha" was banned by the bbc. Crazy.
Blueyes01 on October 04, 2010:
Wow. I didn't know that the funny song "they're coming to take me away ha-haa" was banned by the bbc. Crazy. Thanks for sharing.
Sue Dixon from Grasmere, Cumbria, UK on September 26, 2010:
A fun read! I never realised Day in the Life or Jackie were banned ( I used to love Scott Walker- I've got the album with Jackie on ). Blessed by a Squid Angel and added to my Angel lens today.
Nathalie Roy from France (Canadian expat) on September 21, 2010:
I am not conservative at all. But I can "understand" why they ban Je t'aime...moi non plus, it certainly disturbed many. But The song relax? I don't really get this. Ok the video is hot, but the song....You need some twisted mind to dig for sexually explicit lyrics.
Jimmie Quick from Memphis, TN, USA on September 14, 2010:
I'm pretty conservative myself, but am not a fan of censorship, so I found your lens quite interesting.
squidoohelp on September 10, 2010:
I think it's funny - I had no idea the BBC ever banned anything. Glad they stopped though.
LouiseKirkpatrick from Lincolnshire, United Kingdom on September 07, 2010:
The BBC have always been barmy - and they still are! I knew quite a lot of these had been banned but not all - and a couple I've never heard before! Great fun - blessed by a Squid Angel :)
Indigo Janson from UK on May 16, 2010:
Stopping back here to give this fun (and very well-researched) lens an ~*~* Angel Blessing *~*~
rewards4life info on March 08, 2010:
A very interesting lens. I never knew about all these songs being banned by BBC. Thanks for sharing.
Mahogany LM on February 18, 2010:
A fun and interesting read indeed. Strange thing is, a certain commonwealth (which will remain nameless) still feels a bit like that TODAY. The more things change, the more they stay the same huh?
Kerri Bee from Upstate, NY on February 14, 2010:
It's funny how these songs that were censored are ones I'd sing along to in the car with my parents and think nothing of it. Music has changed so much.
Kimsworld LM on February 12, 2010:
I love music, and facts about it. This was a very well put together lens, I didn't realize the BBC was so strict back then. I'll bet it's not that way now.
Ceeshell on February 12, 2010:
It's funny how buttoned-up radio used to be and how pretty much anything goes nowadays. A fun read!
Nochipra on February 11, 2010:
A Very Interesting Lens! I never knew these were banned and never heard some of them. 5*
FlynntheCat1 on February 10, 2010:
Ha! Great lens. Just wish I wasn't at work and could listen :D I'll have to come back...
Nancy Tate Hellams from Pendleton, SC on February 10, 2010:
Wow, I remember all of these and don't remember them being banned anywhere. Isn't that interesting. This whole lens was so interesting and entertaining. I thoroughly enjoyed. Thanks.
drifter0658 lm on February 09, 2010:
Stellar list....I'd play every one of 'em!
Mary Beth Granger from O'Fallon, Missouri, USA on February 09, 2010:
Interesting lens...I had never heard about these songs being banned. Thanks for sharing the information.
justholidays on February 08, 2010:
Brilliant! Most are songs I love... Ah, nowadays, we're free to listen to them...
Blessed by a SquidAngel.
Indigo Janson from UK on February 07, 2010:
I know the songs but didn't know they had been banned. Learnt something new here! Thanks for yet another interesting and well put-together lens.
pkmcr from Cheshire UK on February 07, 2010:
Some of these certainly bring back memories! Yes Good Old Auntie Beeb has always wanted to protect us hasn't she :-)
Cynthia Arre from Quezon City on February 06, 2010:
I enjoyed some of these songs when I was a teen but I didn't take much notice of the lyrics so i'm surprised to find out (just now!) that they were banned in the UK! Wow. The alleged "inappropriateness" of these songs don't even compare to what can be heard on the airwaves today. Very engaging & well presented! *blessed*
Holley Web on February 06, 2010:
Loved it! These days, these songs wouldn't even get a batted eyelash!
GrowWear on February 06, 2010:
Banned songs? Gracious, didn't know the BBC was as upti, er, contro, er, conscientious as the US. :)
CCGAL on February 06, 2010:
This was a GREAT topic, and the lens has been well produced. This will be a great one to share on Twitter. Some of the songs I never heard, but there were some that surprised me by their presence. Excellent work. 5* a Fav and a Follow.