Skip to main content

The Real Reason Why Solange Attacked Beyonce's Husband Jay-Z in the Elevator

A-List Celebs: Beyonce & Jay-Z

Beyonce and Jay Z

Beyonce and Jay Z

Jay-Z & Solange Fight in Elevator

You Haven't Seen it Yet?

If you haven't seen the most-talked about video in the world right now, please take a moment to view TMZ's video of Solange attacking Jay-Z in the elevator.

An Idea of How Much Beyonce's Privacy Means to Her

Beyonce's Privacy Exposed

Beyoncé is one of the A-list celebrities who strives hard to maintain a sense of privacy even though her life is on a stage for the world to view. When prompted to speak about her private life, both she and her husband give very vague responses, or decline to answer certain questions. In a life where you give every part of you to the world, it’s understandable that there’s a small part that she would like to keep for herself. However, a recent video released by TMZ has shockingly revealed a part of Beyoncé’s personal life that I’m certain she did not want the world to be aware of. This video shows footage (without audio) of Jay-Z, Beyoncé, and Solange entering the elevator to leave the Met Gala event. Inside the elevator, we see a very irate Solange attacking Jay-Z while the bodyguards try to keep her away from him. Beyoncé stands off to the side, doing nothing, and often looking down at the floor.

This leaves the world with one burning question: What in the world did Jay-Z do to piss Solange off like that?

Beyonce & Solange

Solange, baby sister of Beyonce, attacker of Jay-Z

Solange, baby sister of Beyonce, attacker of Jay-Z

What in the world did Jay-Z do to piss Solange off like that?

The truth to this question is that we will probably never know what really triggered Solange’s anger. However, we can make speculations as to what happened based on factual evidence.

Evidence 1: As the video clearly shows, Solange was already pissed before they even walked onto the elevator because before the doors could barely close, she lit into him.

Evidence 2: This wasn’t a little bit of anger. Solange’s anger was off the scale. Not only did she punch at him with her fists and try to kick him, but she also spat at him and tried to get back at him numerous times while the bodyguards held her at bay.

Evidence 3: Not once did Beyoncé look surprised by the outburst, neither did she try to come between them until the very end of the footage when they were about to step off the elevator.

Evidence 4: Solange was saying something to Jay-Z, truly giving him a piece of her mind and Beyoncé didn’t seem to be interrupting Solange’s verbal onslaught.

Evidence 5: When Solange leaves the hotel, she does not look intoxicated, and she is not struggling to walk upright.

Evidence 6: When they were about to enter their limo, the bodyguard would not let Jay-Z inside the limo. Solange enters the limo first and just before Beyoncé dips her head into the limo, she gives a little smile.

Wendy Willaim's Interview Shows Even More Evidence!

What Does this Evidence Means?

Like Wendy Williams points out in her interview, this exchange between Solange and Jay-Z is not a first-time occurrence. If this was a first-time occurrence, Beyoncé would have been doing something—holding up her hands at her sister, trying to talk to her, calm her, something—to diffuse the situation. Solange’s attack on Jay-Z almost seems like she’s trying to take up for/protect her sister’s best interest. Jay-Z did something. Whatever it is that he did, it pissed Solange off to the point that she was no longer able to control her anger.

Jay-Z & Beyonce, Solange upset at how he's treating her sister?

Jay-Z & Beyonce, Solange upset at how he's treating her sister?

Is Jay-Z Disrespecting Beyoncé?

Beyoncé keeps her personal life private so we do not really know what’s going on in her marriage, but we can make some speculations. Wendy suggests that at the Met Gala, Jay-Z may have intentionally brushed against the buttocks of one of his old flames while Beyoncé was standing right there, and Solange saw the indiscretion. She goes on to suggest that this isn’t the first time that Jay-Z disrespected Beyoncé in this type of manner and Solange has basically had enough of his bull. Thus, she sets it off in the elevator, taking up for her big sister and letting Jay-Z know that she’s not going to allow him to hurt her.

Beyonce not wearing her ring

Beyonce not wearing her ring

Beyonce eyeing Jay-Z on the low to see who he's texting

Beyonce eyeing Jay-Z on the low to see who he's texting

Scroll to Continue

Mayhem in the Marriage?

Could it be true that not all is well on the marital front for Beyoncé and Jay-Z? Well, we don’t know the facts, but evidence suggests that there may be some trouble in paradise.

Evidence 1: Beyoncé has been spotted not wearing her wedding ring.

Evidence 2: Beyoncé was secretly eyeing Jay-Z’s phone while he was texting at a game.

Evidence 3: Remember, Beyoncé gave a brilliant smile just before dipping her head into the limo—what is there to smile about after your younger sister just open a can of whoopit on your husband just seconds before the limo ride?

Family Releases a Statement

According to CBS, Beyoncé, Jay-Z, and Solange released a public statement concerning what transpired in the elevator. Beyonce states, “They both acknowledge their role in this private matter that has played out in the public. They both have apologized to each other and we have moved forward as a united family,” (CBS, 2014). However, the statement gives no insight into what triggered the attack in the elevator. You can read the entire article here:

What Do YOU Think?

In Closing

Speculation 1: Jay-Z did something very inappropriate that disrespected Beyoncé, and it’s very likely that this isn’t the first time that he’s stepped out of line.

Speculation 2: Solange’s love for her sister and outrage at her brother-in-law’s lack of respect for Beyoncé motivated Solange to attack him in the elevator to let him know how she really feels about his behavior.

This family will continue to maintain their sense of privacy. I believe Solange is burning to let the world know what’s really going on with Jay-Z, but she loves her sister so dearly that she respects Beyoncé’s desire to keep her marriage private. But I believe that the leaking of this video is just the beginning, because there is nothing hidden that will not be disclosed, nothing concealed that will not be brought out in the open (Luke 12:2).

© 2014 Jessica B Smith


Jessica B Smith (author) from Sanford, NC on May 23, 2014:

Wow, that's crazy! Again, thank you for sharing your thoughts on this hub. I have 4 young children, 2 girls, 2 boys, and I am teaching my children to keep their hands to themselves. I'm a very non-physical person and I plan to teach my children to be non-physical as well because like you point out, once a woman lays her hands on a man, he has the right to hit her back. Avoid the situation all together by keeping your hands to yourself--male or female.

dashingscorpio from Chicago on May 22, 2014:

Thanks for your feedback. My argument for the most part has little to do with how hard a man hits a woman. I'm simply saying the woman should (never) hit a man period and not expect to get hit back!

If I had a daughter I would strongly advise her not to (initiate) any physical violence towards men. It's simply not a smart move! No one should be hitting anyone.

As for Zimmerman I feel like he was completely in the wrong the moment the 911 operator told him NOT to follow or confront Trayvon Martin. If a black man shot and a killed a 17 year old white male after being instructed not to confront the teen he would not have been allowed to go home that evening let alone be vindicated in court.

A few weeks afterwards a black woman in Florida shot a "warning shot" against her said to be violent husband under the guise of "stand your ground" and she was sentenced to 20 years! (She did not even wound her husband).

Jessica B Smith (author) from Sanford, NC on May 22, 2014:

Dashingscorpio, I just finished reading your hub and just as I expected, it was a very thought-provoking read! You really did your research and I'm glad you are giving a voice to the "Double Standard." At the same time, I have to point out that women are the weaker vessels (physically) and this has to be taken into account. In the above example, I don't think this man should've hit her back (with equal force) because of his size compared to hers, even if she did decide to "slap a grizzly bear" (by the way, I love that analogy). While I feel that a man has every right to hit a woman back if she hits him, just because it is your right doesn't mean you have to act on it. Take Zimmerman for example. It was his right to "stand his ground" and to use deadly force to do so. Even though it was his right and the courts acquitted him, what he did wasn't morally right. I give this example to demonstrate that though you have a right to do something, you can use your best judgment to see whether or not you should activate that right or if there's a better way to handle the situation.

That being said, I do like that you are giving a voice to men who are assaulted because a lot of men remain silent about this situation because they don't want to be considered a wuss, a woman-beater, etc. Yes, there are many women out there in domestic violence situations, but there are also many men out there who are being beaten, slapped, spit on, punched, cut, etc. by an angry partner and they won't fight back because of the Double Standard. They need an advocate as well because just as you put it, wrong is wrong.

I believe there's a way to fight against the Double Standard without the man balling up his fists to retaliate--though he has every right to. Already, some changes have been made. Now, whenever a domestic violence call is made, if the man has visible bruises on him as well, both he and the female can be arrested for assault. Back in the day, this was not so. If that woman was hurt, the man was going to jail. Period.

dashingscorpio from Chicago on May 22, 2014:

No, I don't think he'd be wrong to hit her back. Being an intelligent person I could never understand why someone would slap a grizzly bear across the face. It makes no sense! Words don't justify violence period.

I once had a woman ask me if the hitting back rule applied if a child hit me. I told her; " Let me put it this way, if I had ever hit my mother I would not be here with you having this discussion!" LOL!

I grew up in an era where we did not have "time-outs" we had "knock-outs". :-) Kids didn't even roll their eyes in front of their parents.

Awhile back I wrote a hub on this very topic of violence double standards.

Jessica B Smith (author) from Sanford, NC on May 22, 2014:

Well put, Dashingscorpio! I'm glad you brought up the issue of the Double Standard (you seem very passionate about the topic; you should consider writing a hub on it--I would definitely read it!) Your post reminds me of a Whoopi Goldberg clip that sparked an outrage. Have you seen it? Basically, she states that if a woman hits a man, he has every right to hit her back. Everyone doesn't agree with this, but I agree to a fault. My motto is: Keep your hands to yourself and our world will be a better place. I have a question for you. If a 95-lb, 5'4" woman got into a heated argument with her 270-lb, 6' husband and he said something so disrespectful that she punched his arm with all her might, do you think he's wrong if he hit her back with all his might?

dashingscorpio from Chicago on May 22, 2014:

Clearly this is one of those "double standards" that society has. As you stated: "This leaves the world with one burning question: What in the world did Jay-Z do to piss Solange off like that?" Is there any real justification?

If a man had attacked a woman in the elevator no one would be asking that question! Instead everyone would be saying: "There is NO justification for a man to put his hands on a woman!"

Odds are the police would have arrested Jay-Z even if no one called them to press charges! The media and viewers would have demanded it!

From time to time I've watched shows like "Cheaters" and "The Maury Povich Show" and whenever a (woman) discovers her man has cheater on her she will slap, take a swing or kick at him. However when a man discovers his woman has cheated on him all he does is (verbally) attack her.

As you said we may never know why Solange blew a fuse. I grew up in an era where my (mother) told me if someone hits you to hit them back! Unlike Jay-Z me and a lot of other guys I know would have retaliated.

Instead of our society preaching that men should not hit women I think it's time to preach (no one should be hitting anyone!)

If a man is not going to hit a woman back he needs to press charges! It's time to put an end to this violent double standard. One man's opinion! :-)

Related Articles