It might seem like a stupid question but does it really matter if singers can't sing well? Most people would say that's their job, so of course, they should be able to sing. But many quickly change their minds when Bob Dylan is brought up. They'll say he can't sing well but it doesn't matter because he's a great songwriter. We all value different things in musical artists and whether we think someone is talented or not depends on what we personally expect from them.
I was amused when The Flaming Lips frontman Wayne Coyne retweeted the following tweet:
"One of the things I love most about @waynecoyne is that he really doesn't have a great voice. Imperfection is the best kind of perfect"
Very few singers want to admit that they aren't great vocalists. Wayne obviously feels secure enough in his many musical talents that being a powerhouse vocalist probably means little to him.
Voices As Instruments
However, some people can only enjoy the songs of great vocalists like Whitney Houston and Mariah Carey, and can't really appreciate even a good singer. They can't enjoy a singer who isn't a powerhouse vocalist. For them, a great voice is like a musical instrument. Imagine an 88-key piano but someone can only play a couple of dozen keys. Maybe they play those keys very well, which many people will enjoy. But others can only appreciate someone who can play all 88 keys.
For people like this not only is being able to sing important but being able to sing at a very high level is important. They can only appreciate a vocalist whose voice can do amazing things. In fact, they often have little interest in the story of a song. They're interested in vocal technique and put a lot of emphasis on vocal ranges, high notes hit, belts, melisma, and vocal runs.
Listening to a great singer can be a lot like listening to a piece of classical music. You generally don't listen for a story. You listen purely for the beauty of the music.
The Story of a Song
I generally tend to dislike great vocalists because their songs often bore me. All my favorite artists are singer/songwriters who have decent to good vocals. A great voice is nice but not necessary for me. These are just a few great songs by artists that aren't great vocalists.
Ben Folds Five Brick
Ben Folds is a songwriter and composer. When I listen to him singing his song Brick, I can imagine the fear of the teenagers in the song who are going behind their parents' backs to have an abortion. Ben Folds may not be a powerhouse vocalist but I can feel the emotion in his voice when he sings about a painful personal experience early in his life.
"Up the stairs, to her apartment
She is balled up on the couch
Her mom and dad went down to Charlotte
They're not home to find us out"
Ben Folds said about the song:
"I didn't really want to write this song from any kind of political standpoint, or make a statement. I just wanted to reflect what it feels like."
And he succeeded in my opinion.
Nanci Griffith Late Night Grande Hotel
Country/folk artist Nanci Griffith has songs like Love at the Five and Dime and Gulf Coast Highway about lifelong love. Yet she was unable to form long-term relationships in her own life. Late Night Grande Hotel is one song where she describes this:
"And maybe you were thinkin'
That you thought you knew me well
But, no one ever knows the heart of anyone else
I feel like Garbo in this late night grand hotel
Cause living alone is all I've ever done well"
Griffith's boyfriend was killed in a motorcycle accident after he took her to their high school prom, she had a failed marriage, an engagement that ended and she struggled with health issues like depression and cancer. A sense of loneliness is palpable in many of her songs.
The Flaming Lips The Yeah Yeah Yeah Song
And great songwriters can make us think. The Flaming Lips ask what kind of choices we might make in The Yeah Yeah Yeah Song:
"If you could blow up the world with the flick of a switch
Would you do it?
If you could make everybody poor just so you could be rich
Would you do it?"
Bob Dylan asks us a series of questions in Blowin' in the Wind:
"Yes, how many years can a mountain exist
Before it's washed to the sea?
Yes, how many years can some people exist
Before they're allowed to be free?
Yes, how many times can a man turn his head
Pretending he just doesn't see?
The answer my friend is blowin' in the wind
The answer is blowin' in the wind."
Ultimately the meaning, story, and what I feel when I hear the songs is what matters the most. The artists in the songs above aren't doing any vocal gymnastics but it doesn't matter because they're telling interesting stories or making us think.
Many people enjoy the tones of their favorite singer's voices and may not care too much about overall vocal ability and technique. This can drive the lovers of powerhouse vocalists crazy. But every singer is a package. We all weigh the ability to sing, perform, play instruments, and write songs differently.
Musical talent is hard to measure. What makes a person a great artist is a matter of opinion. Songwriting ability is subjective depending on what we value in a song. Maybe it's best if we all just enjoy the artists we personally love and leave others to enjoy the artists they love even if they aren't our cup of tea.
© 2013 Learn Things Web
Learn Things Web (author) from California on August 03, 2015:
The public doesn't often care about levels of talent. They like what they like. Personally, I would have a hard time listening to someone who I didn't feel was talented in some way though.
Mel on July 31, 2015:
Considering that vocalists make up a minority of influential popular artists over the years, it doesn't seem like the public cares a whole lot about vocal ability. It's whether a song speaks to them that matters the most. I don't care if a singer can reach three, four or five octaves or any of that. It's what they do with whatever talent the have that matters.
Learn Things Web (author) from California on July 24, 2015:
I think Ben Fold's is a good singer just like I think Nanci Griffith and Kesha are. Heck, even Wayne Coyne is not bad. For many people though they aren't good singers because being a good singer means having Whitney Houston level vocals. Ben doesn't have that at all. Whether you think someone can sing or not is often subjective rather than objective because people have different ideas of what being able to sing means. My point is it really doesn't matter whether someone sounds like Amy Winehouse or like Bob Dylan. If you like the music they make, why does it matter.
DoubleA on July 23, 2015:
Try singing a Ben Folds song in front of people. Not easy. He is a very good vocalist.
Learn Things Web (author) from California on March 12, 2014:
Powerhouse vocalists make up a small minority of popular singers since the 60's, so yes if you narrowly define being able to sing, most great artists over the years couldn't sing. I think that's going too far.
Sid on March 11, 2014:
Whether you think someone can sing or not depends on how you define being able to sing. I think it's ridiculous to say if someone isn't a Sam Cooke or an Amy Winehouse, they can't sing. I think if someone can stay on key most of the time and are pleasant to listen to, then they can sing. If you set the standard too high then most great artists like The Beatles, Hendrix, Springsteen can't sing when in fact they sound fine live.
Learn Things Web (author) from California on December 26, 2013:
It's definitely true that a lot of the respected classic rock vocalists really weren't great singers. They were great artists but not great vocalists.
Janis from California on December 26, 2013:
I think when it comes to rock, a lot of singers don't have great voices, compared to the beautiful voices opera singers have.
Learn Things Web (author) from California on November 07, 2013:
I understand exactly what you're saying. I've sometimes disliked the lyrics of a song but liked the overall sound of the song. Or I'll find the lyrics interesting even if the overall production is a little boring. I'll often understand why people love songs I dislike but there are some successful songs I don't see the appeal of at all.
No one wants to listen to an opera singer who can't sing.
Joe Poniatowskis from Mid-Michigan on November 07, 2013:
In pop music, if a song has great vocals, I can forgive cheesy lyrics. If I strongly identify with the lyrics, then I'm not too worried about the vocal talent of the singer. If it has neither, it had better be an impressive instrumental number. I understand that music appreciation is rather subjective, but even so, I'm always a little surprised at songs that enjoy commercial success in spite of lacking moving lyrics, great vocals, *or* exceptional instrumentation.
CJ on November 06, 2013:
I love opera but I also love rock and pop. For opera obviously vocals are the most important thing. For rock and pop, lyrics and production matter the most.
Learn Things Web (author) from California on November 06, 2013:
I don't think great vocals are important in pop, rock, country and folk music. They are important in opera, jazz, and musical theater. So, it really does depend on the genre.
Hezekiah from Japan on November 05, 2013:
I think if it's mainstream factory made pop, then I doesn't really matter. With technology such as Autotune, we can fix anybodies pitch problems while having it sound natural. For other genres, singing skill will be important, but the most important things is to have character and stand out.