Updated date:

Metallica "St Anger": A Review of the Most Criticized Metallica Album

Ara is a Journalism graduate from California State University Northridge who is always looking to explore his writing opportunities.

This picture symbolizes what is on the album cover for St. Anger.

This picture symbolizes what is on the album cover for St. Anger.

St. Anger Songs List

  1. Frantic
  2. St. Anger
  3. Some Kind of Monster
  4. Dirty Window
  5. Invisible Kid
  6. My World
  7. Shoot Me Again
  8. Sweet Amber
  9. The Unnamed Feeling
  10. Purify
  11. All Within My Hands

St. Anger Is the Most Criticized Album of Metallica's Career

In the long career of American heavy metal band Metallica, there is one album that has gotten lots of criticism for its quality. That album is St. Anger. I have to admit that I did not like this album very much either when I first heard it. In fact, I really did not start to like it until 2014. That’s a full 11 years after the album’s release. St. Anger should get much more credit than it does as a heavy metal album than it does. This article looks at the great and not so great aspects of an album that has received more criticism than praise. St. Anger must be give more credit and this heavy metal fan is here to tell you why. But before we do, let me just say that for some reason, St. Anger is the one album that seems to improve my mood more than the other Metallica albums do.

For what Metallica has been through in their career as a band, St. Anger shows that they reinvented themselves and still did a pretty good job

St. Anger is the album that is looked upon as Metallica’s weakest album musically and it has especially been seen as a piece of garbage by the band’s hardcore fan base, the ones that remember Metallica for their outstanding albums of the 1980’s. By the time this album was released, the band had been through enough hardship already. If a band wants to grow and mature musically, they have to experiment with different styles. Metallica started this process with their self-titled black album in 1991. They would experiment further with the albums Load (1996) and Re-load (1997). It would not be until 2003 that St. Anger would be released. The most noticeable difference with St. Anger compared to the band’s other albums is the drum sound. This is the one aspect that I believe has received the most criticism from fans more than anything else. I did not like the drum sound in the album either for a very long time. But St. Anger has a kind of ferocity in the guitar playing that we have not seen since And Justice for All back in 1988. This is one of the reasons that St. Anger should receive more credit than it does. At least the album is heavy, something that Metallica started with early in their career. It has the kind of raw, aggressive sound that even I enjoy. I prefer to listen to Metallica more than other American metal bands such as Helstar or Exodus. If people do not like St. Anger that is totally fine. But music is a creative way for an artist to express themselves. Metallica really lets out their anger and frustration out with this album and these guys are good at what they do and they are able to attract fans from all over the world. That’s why they have lasted so long as a band. Get ready to hear one of the most raw-sounding albums that is full of anger but this kind of anger and emotion expressed is healthy because it is expressed through the creative power of music!

"St. Anger" Song Only

St. Anger's Strongest Songs

The strongest songs are Frantic, Invisible Kid, Shoot Me Again, Purify, and The Unnamed Feeling. "Dirty Window" has tons of drumming and is a heavy song as well. St. Anger (the song) expresses the emotion of anger in a humorous kind of way. But from the start of the album, you know the band is ready to show that they can still heavy kind of sound and keep the listener interested. St. Anger should receive more credit than it deserves as a heavy metal album for its heaviness, raw sound, and pounding drums even though the quality is sub-standard. I realize that some people may be turned off by the way James Hetfield utters the words "frantic tick tick tick tick tick tock." But the song "Frantic" because of its aggression and heaviness can really provide a very solid opening song for an album that has received so much criticism.

The humorous nature of the song St. Anger may help some of you put things in perspective. If you are angry, feeling trapped, and desperate for a change, St. Anger is going to change your mood really fast!

What are the great aspects of St. Anger?

St. Anger is the first Metallica album to not have Jason Newsted playing the bass guitar. Although Robert Trujillo is listed in the album credits, Bob Rock played the bass guitar during the recording of the album. St. Anger is another one of those very long albums being over 70 minutes long. The album has plenty of groove in it, especially the song called “Shoot Me Again.” This song causes lots of excitement for me and is one of my favorites in the album. For those that enjoy heavy, hard hitting groove metal, St. Anger should be good enough to listen to. I admit that St. Anger is different and many people are turned off by this. But if you give St. Anger enough of a chance, you may enjoy it like I do now. For those music fans that are open minded and willing to explore something different, St. Anger is one of those albums that you may like. On the other hand, if you enjoy Metallica’s earlier albums, St. Anger will be a disappointment. Is this Metallica’s weakest album? Most fans of the band will say that it is. I would say that because I’m an open minded listener, I would find it hard to say that it is their worst album musically. Even though Load and Re-Load have guitar solos, they do not have the ferocity and heaviness of St. Anger. Re-load has the song The Memory Remains which is one of the weakest songs in Metallica’s career because of the addition of vocals by Marianne Faithful which make no sense.

Best Song on the album St. Anger

The Cons of the Album St. Anger

The obvious cons for St. Anger are the drums which sound like someone is pounding on tin cans and the lack of guitar solos. These are two major reasons why St. Anger is not one of the band’s strongest musical efforts on par with Master of Puppets, And Justice for All, and even Death Magnetic. The song "My World" sounds like the song Creeping Death in the beginning. This is one of those songs that has lots of repetition and may be the weakest song on St. Anger. But even so, St. Anger has grooves, speed, and a ferocity that has not been seen since the band’s early days.

"The Unnamed Feeling" (official music video)

Updated Review for St. Anger

So for an updated version of this review, let us go through most of the songs on St. Anger and they are listed in no particular order of greatness. We will discuss the songs that have not been elaborated in.

  1. Frantic - This opening song really shows that Metallica comes out of the gate full speed ahead with their new brand of musical ferocity in the 21st century. There is a constant uttering of frantic, tick-tock by James Hetfield and some fans will find this annoying but it is a good opener for the album. I suppose some of you will wonder why the band decided to include a melodic singing part of “keep on searching.” They wanted to make things a little more varied since there are no guitar solos on the album.
  2. St. Anger - This song has shades of the band’s early days as Hetfield mentions the phrase no regrets. I certainly have no regrets listening to this album. There are time changes that keep on happening throughout this 7+ minute song.
  3. Dirty Window - This song has A LOT of tin can style drumming in it. Who really wants to clean dirty windows? However, the song starts out with furious vocals by James Hetfield as he speaks about seeing his reflection in the window as it looks different compared to what some people would see. A clean house is definitely important and some of you may see the humor in this statement as this song is entertaining too as well.
  4. The Unnamed Feeling - This song had to be on this list of the updated review because of the fact that it is a power ballad. Prior to this song, Metallica didn’t really have a power ballad.
  5. Purify - This song is an all-out assault on the ear drums as the heaviness is made heavier by the guitars including the drum sound. We need help to purify this world from some of the evils in it.
  6. Some Kind of Monster -This third song starts out with some Black Sabbath doom sound which is not something we hear from Metallica very often and this song takes a while to grow on you musically.
  7. Invisible Kid - This song starts out with a catchy as heck riff as the drumming kicks in. The song might have lyrics in it that don’t make the most sense but the song has heaviness, decent vocals, and moderate riffing that is memorable even in 2019.
  8. Sweet Amber – This song has a rather unusual start to it as it slowly builds up into a rather heavy and humorous song as there is the sentence “how sweet does it get?”


Rate the Album St. Anger

"Dirty Window"

Final Thoughts About St. Anger in 2020

After reviewing St. Anger in 2020, it now gets an 80 out of 100 points making it a better album than Load or Re-Load. In a remarkable turn of events, I view St. Anger as one of the best albums of the modern era (early 2000’s to the present). St. Anger has a musical ferocity and anger that even kill ‘Em All back in 1983 did not have. Metallica’s debut album had that new kind of thrash metal aggressiveness but St. Anger is a musical example that Metallica still has what it takes in terms of creating a brilliant modern day groove metal album. St. Anger definitely is better than albums such as Reinventing the Steel.

© 2016 Ara Vahanian