Updated date:

Whatever Happened to the Mayflower?

Jason Ponic works in the exciting world of Hollywood film and television by day and writes by night.


The Legend

She has been a common part of the American Lexicon for nearly two centuries. Her name is taught to every school child in the United States. Everyone knows the story of her passengers and the reasons they came to America. But what is never taught is the fate of the ship herself. What became of the ship that has become an indelible part of American Culture?

The Ship

Since photography would not be invented for another two hundred years, no photographs exist of the Mayflower. In fact, so little information regarding the ship survives that there is no official account as to the appearance of the vessel. There was no comprehension as to the historic significance of the voyage the vessel was about to embark so no effort was made to document it.

Historians agree that the Mayflower likely looked like any other three masted cargo ship of the era. A carrack outfitted with square and lateen rigging with a length between 90 and 110 feet and a weight of 180 tons, the average. She was built in early 1600s. She changed masters twice, the original ending up in prison after a debt default. Between 1609 and 1622 under the command of Captain Christopher Jones, she was based in Rotherhithe as served as a merchant ship for the wine trade.

The Reality of the Voyage

The version told to American Schoolchildren is greatly under-dramatized and highly inaccurate. While some children's books made mention that the voyage was long and hard, it was an understatement. The voyage was nothing short of Hell on Earth.

The Puritans were an illegal religious organization in England. Therefore, little money was available to properly finance the expedition to the New World. As a result, they could only afford to charter two tiny cargo ships for the transatlantic voyage, the Speedwell and the Mayflower. The Speedwell, a rebuilt 60 ton freighter, already 30 years old by the time it was chartered for the Voyage, was plagued with leaks. Originally setting sail on August 5, 1620, the Speedwell's leaking caused the voyage to be delayed twice by over a month. During that time, twenty passengers left the expedition permanently, either out of frustration or financial hardship, nobody knows for sure. In fact, money problems became so bad, it forced the Puritans to sell off most of their whale oil and butter for the voyage. It would resume on September 6, 1620. This time only the Mayflower would make the crossing. She was overloaded with the remainder of the Speedwell's passengers and cargo.

The Mayflower was never intended for passenger travel. In total over 130 people were crammed into the cargo deck of the ship, some couldn't even lay down flat. In a modern analogy, imagine stuffing 75 people into the back of a semi tractor trailer and driving from Los Angeles to New York four times non stop with no air conditioning or heating all while dumping your waste off the back of the truck.

Storms nearly sank the ship several times during the crossing. The main base of the ship broke at one point and a couple crew members were washed overboard. Subsequently the ship was blown completely off course and rather then landing in Virginia, the Mayflower landed far to the north in what would become Massachusetts 66 days later. Scurvy and other diseases were a major problem during the voyage, ultimately claiming the lives of two people.



In 1621, the Mayflower returned to England with news of the Plimouth Colony's success and after the death of her master, Christopher Jones in 1622, information all but disappears. Some historians believe the Mayflower was retired to harbor duty, where it fell into disrepair. The Port of London, too busy transporting goods from America, did not see the need to preserve the Mayflower as something of historical importance. With a scrap value of £128 for its wood, anchors, sails and galley equipment, the ship was sold for scrap sometime in the late 1620s.


Mayflower was a very common name in the 1600s. A second Mayflower voyaged to Plimouth Colony eight years after the original returned. It brought 35 new passengers and provisions for the colony. This vessel made the crossing several times between 1630 and 1639. The vessel sank with all 142 passengers and crew lost in late 1641 on route for Virginia.


Mayflower Barn

In 1920, 300 years after the original voyage, a book was published by J. Rendel Harris, an antiquarian, that describes the ship's ultimate fate. In 1624 the ship was broken up and its timbers sold as scrap. During that time Farmer Thomas Russell bought ship timbers to use in the construction of his barn in South Buckinghamshire. Harris calls this proof that the barn was in fact made from the timbers of the now legendary Mayflower. There is no concrete way to validate this claim.


Mayflower II

In the 1950s a replica of the original Mayflower was built in collaboration between English millionaire Warwrick Harlton and The Plimoth Plantation Museum. Using reconstructed blueprints the ship was built in England using authentic materials and construction methods. The oak was carefully chosen, the nails were hand forged and the sails were hand sewn. She was launched in an authentic christening ceremony in 1956. In 1957 the Mayflower II recreated the original voyage, sailing from England to Plymouth The Museum of Plimoth Plantation maintains the ship to this day, the ship set sail in 2007 to commemorate it's 50th anniversary.

This content is accurate and true to the best of the author’s knowledge and is not meant to substitute for formal and individualized advice from a qualified professional.


sean1a6plane-a-holic on December 20, 2019:

Nice! I got anA onHIstory for This

Percy Jackson the demigod on December 12, 2017:

Nice documents it helped me on my mayflower report and I got a four on it!!! :)

Alaine deBreaux on April 23, 2017:

The second Mayflower left England in 1629, commanded by my ancestor, Capt. William Pierce.

Kurt on August 11, 2013:

Minus the typos,...especially Plimoth (Plymouth) :D It's an interesting article.

Paul Swendson on April 08, 2013:

Interesting topic. My understanding is that the Pilgrims - generally referred to as Separatists at the time - did not get much attention from the general public until the early 20th century. So if the Plymouth Colony did not get much attention for hundreds of years, it is not surprising that no one for a long time would bother to find out what happened to the boat.

It is also my understanding that only about 1/3 of the people on that initial voyage were Pilgrims.

Person on April 05, 2013:


Jason Ponic (author) from Albuquerque on May 31, 2012:

Thank you Judi! The fate of the Mayflower has always been an interest of mine.

Judi Brown from UK on May 31, 2012:

New angle to an old story - very interesting!

Voted up etc.

Movie Master from United Kingdom on May 06, 2012:

An excellent hub on the history of the Mayflower, lots of information I never knew, voting up and interesting

thank you!

Jason Ponic (author) from Albuquerque on May 05, 2012:

That's exciting to hear! Thank you so much!

Pamela Oglesby from Sunny Florida on May 04, 2012:

This is an interesting account of the history of the Mayflower. I have also studied its history as a genealogist. I had the opportunity to tour the replica about 3 years ago, which was a real treat. One of my ancestors was washed overboard but fortunately he was saved. Voted up and interesting.

ThoughtSandwiches from Reno, Nevada on May 04, 2012:


An excellent hub which answers the question I never thought to ask! Great job...I look forward to reading more of your stuff!


Faith Reaper from southern USA on May 04, 2012:

Very interesting. Voted up. I

Jason Ponic (author) from Albuquerque on May 04, 2012:

Thank you!

Jeff Berndt from Southeast Michigan on May 04, 2012:

Nifty hub, with good information about the old Mayflower. Voted up and interesting!