Tamara Wilhite is a technical writer, industrial engineer, mother of two, and published sci-fi and horror author.
Jon Ronson’s 2015 book So You’ve Been Publicly Shamed interviews a number of prominent victims of online shaming like Christine Sacco. The tragedy is how many other cases have popped up since his book was published, some of them more prominent than the individuals he featured in his book, others punished more systematically than his named victims. Let's look at some of the events that have transpired since Mr. Ronson's book came out.
High Profile Targets and Their Fates
Scott Adams of Dilbert fame, Stefan Molyneux and others have described the act of ganging up on someone to tear them down as an addictive dopamine rush that all in power tend to have and crave more of. For the average person, joining in with a mob makes them more powerful and vicious than they would be alone, while the encouragement of their peers to go farther and do worse; this is a uniquely human flaw that leads to evil (not just taking pleasure in their pain but competing to make it worse).
When Scott Adams spoke publicly in favor of Trump’s persuasion techniques, not only did he get shadowbanned from Twitter and see his speaking engagements disappear, Twitter attacked his then-girlfriend by de-verifying her so that people didn’t know which account was really hers and which was one of many pretenders. This happens through even mainstream news outlets, like when the wife of Vice President Pence’s phone number was published by the Associated Press; this information was irrelevant to public discourse and was known to cause a wave of liberal bullying directed at her, but they did it anyway.
When Twitter can penalize the girlfriend of a celebrity for his politically incorrect statement, when the AP can punish the wife of a politician, of course liberal bullies see it as fair to go after the friends, family and other relationships of anyone else they deem worthy of destruction.
And the Fates of Smaller Targets
I commend Mr. Ronson for going back to talk to the victims of excessively disproportionate online shaming to the point of losing their jobs; he doesn’t spend much time on the deliberate undermining of their relationships by hate mobs that didn’t see the victims or their friends and family as real people, like when Youtuber Sargon of Akkad did a video on Social Justice as a cult and had people try to drive away his girlfriend in addition to being flagged as hate speech in an effort to cost him his stream of income. I read William Shetterley condemning this as the “weaponization of poverty”, not just seeking to shame them but punish them with material suffering, too.
The weaponization of poverty and attempts to silence dissent by putting their very livelihoods at risk is a standard tactic. Shutting down websites through DDoS, flagging all Youtube videos by someone as hate speech to get them demonetized (aside from Youtube’s own liberally biased demonetization policies), organized campaigns to get people fired from their jobs and simultaneously render them unemployable are depressingly common. It isn’t enough to hurt someone emotionally by sending lots of hateful tweets (ironically often in the name of love), let’s hurt them physically and emotionally by costing them their homes, their ability to buy food, make their children and spouses afraid for their safety and upset from the bullying, too.
Let’s take an example of this “digital shaming” taken to the next level. Ashley Rae Goldenberg published a politically incorrect poem, and SJWs responded by threatening to kill her family, trying to get her kicked out of school, and published the family’s phone numbers and credit card numbers. And Ms. Goldenberg is far from the only person to have family members threatened or harassed in this way.
Once the target of the two-minute hate is selected, liberal bullies see nothing as off-limits and do anything and everything possible to ruin the lives of the target until a new target is offered up for abuse. If the prison chapters are true on a wider scale, liberal bullies risk creating a few dark and hardened souls from among their many innocent victims, people capable of the atrocities they say incorrect word choice are associated with. That their ever-changing moral codes and victimhood hierarchies leave everyone afraid and vulnerable to such assaults shuts down true dialogue and emboldens the violent authoritarians.
The solution isn’t more shaming, greater consequences, escalating to violence against the assigned guilty party of the moment. It is compassion for the pain the actions likely cause, humility by those who are getting high off the digital lynching, and empathy. Because when the official accepted viewpoints are ever-changing per social justice, it really could be any of us at any time.
And if the solution is as Mr. Ronson fears saying nothing, doing nothing, becoming as bland as possible to avoid any reason for assault by the mob, freedom of speech, the honest exchange of ideas that prevent excesses and lead to innovation, all die. And silent terror of the hate mobs does nothing to stop them, either.
Yet Mr. Ronson’s solution per his book remains true – have empathy for the victim of the hate mob of the moment; this is the person being attacked, not the supposedly aggrieved groups that may, might or say they are offended. The solution is a recognition that the victims of these digital lynch mobs are people, not some target in a video game to be taken down as aggressively and creatively as possible. The solution is empathy, understanding, and recognition that great evil can be committed under any moral banner, even “love” and “tolerance”.
- Dilbert cartoonist says he lost income and jobs after saying Trump would win
- Should Twitter and Facebook be Regulated as Utilities?: In this article, Scott Adams discusses the repeated deverification of his then-girlfriend as a punishment for his political stances as well as his own shadowban on Twitter.
- Student (Ashley Ray Goldenberg) threatened with rape, death after Ferguson poem
- Fired dispatcher who is Trump supporter given job back
- Schoolteachers fired for pro-Trump remarks - off campus!
- 'You're fired,' Houston TV station tells reporter who made pro-Trump Facebook post
- Liberal profs admit they’d discriminate against conservatives in hiring, advancement
- Professor who tweeted against PC culture is out at NYU
- Twitter Shadowbanning ‘Real and Happening Every Day’ Says Inside Source
- The Social Media Hive Mind by Scott Adams: In this, Scott Adams examines the "throttling" of his tweets and shared links.
© 2017 Tamara Wilhite
Tamara Wilhite (author) from Fort Worth, Texas on March 04, 2018:
Right now, Margret Atwood, author of "The Handmaid's Tale" and Steven Pinker, the researcher.
Tamara Wilhite (author) from Fort Worth, Texas on October 19, 2017:
Rachael Lefler I've stopped trying to keep the Hub up to date because of the sheer volume of incidents. It is disappointing that liberal bullies have used the internet to attack people they don't actually know or ever deal with, because it was the social ties to the shaming victim that kept the acts under control when the practice was followed in the 1600s.
For example, the mob had to mediate its insults and actions because they had to live with the neighbors for years afterward and mutual friends would check the mobs' actions.
Whether bullying people online or tracking down a stranger's phone number to send threatening messages, technology has removed those constraints while multiplying the number of attackers.
Tamara Wilhite (author) from Fort Worth, Texas on March 06, 2017:
The problem with the "fake news" meme is that liberal sources tend to check against liberal sources, and when liberal sources don't report matters like Clinton's health problems, the few outlets that DO report it are flagged as "fake".
The other problem with "research for yourself" is that the mainstream media picks up the wave of outrage and rarely goes to the heart of the matter and uses the story to fit their narratives ... it gets framed as X privileged person offended Y group, and the truth is lost.
Rachael Lefler from Illinois on March 06, 2017:
One solution is don't believe things you hear in the news or on social media without investigating the facts of the matter yourself.
Tamara Wilhite (author) from Fort Worth, Texas on March 06, 2017:
Mr. Ronson's solution is for us to have empathy for the people that are too often sent horrific threats because they don't seem like people when we're sitting in front of a screen. In short, see them as people and recognize that given trends, it easily could be any of us.
Yes, some of the targets of various incidents have committing suicide.
threekeys on March 05, 2017:
What was the authour's solution to getting them to stop ? Or did the targets end up homeless or commit suicide? Did any authourities step in to help the targets?
Rachael Lefler from Illinois on March 05, 2017:
"Once the target of the two minute hate is selected, liberal bullies see nothing as off limits and do anything and everything possible to ruin the lives of the target until a new target is offered up for abuse. " Yep, it's fucking sad. Pewdiepie, Milo, who won't they target?